Abstract:Abstract This work presents a decision-making methodology that allows the merging of quantitative and qualitative decision variables for selecting the optimal metal Additive Manufacturing (AM) technology. The approach is applied on two competing technologies in the field of metal AM industry, i.e., the metal extrusion AM process (metal FFF) and the Laser Powder Bed Fusion process (LPBF) with single and multiple lasers, which represent the benchmark solution currently on the market. A comprehensive techno-economical comparison is presented where the two processes are analysed in terms of process capabilities (quality, easiness of use, setup time, range of possible materials, etc.) and costs, considering two different production scenarios and different parts’ geometries. In the first scenario, the AM system is assumed to be dedicated to one single part production while in this second scenario, the AM system is assumed to be saturated, as devoted to producing a wide mix of part types. For each scenario, two different part types made of 17–4 PH stainless steel are considered as a reference to investigate the effect of shape complexity, part size and production times to select the best technology when metal FFF and LPBF must be considered. The first part type refers to an extrusion die, to represent typical shapes of interest in the tooling industry, while the second part type is an impeller which can be used in many different industrial sectors, ranging from oil and gas to aerospace. In order to include quantitative and qualitative criteria, a decision-making model based on Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) is proposed as the enabler tool for decision making. The proposed approach allows to determine the most effective solution depending on the different production configurations and part types and can be used as a guideline and extended to include other technologies in the field of metal AM. On the other side, the critical discussion of the criteria selected, and the results achieved allow to highlight the pros and cons of the competing technologies, thus defining the existing limits to define directions for future research.

Insourcing additive manufacturing for spare parts production: is it profitable? An extensive analysis and the proposal of a Decision Support System

Improving effectiveness of spare parts supply by additive manufacturing as dual sourcing option

Choosing between additive and conventional manufacturing of spare parts: On the impact of failure rate uncertainties and the tools to reduce them

A multi-period multiple parts mixed integer linear programming model for AM adoption in the spare parts supply Chain

Informing Additive Manufacturing technology adoption: total cost and the impact of capacity utilisation

Switchover to industrial additive manufacturing: dynamic decision-making for problematic spare parts

Additive Manufacturing Technology In Spare Parts Supply Chain: A Comparative Study

A techno-economic approach for decision-making in metal additive manufacturing: metal extrusion versus single and multiple laser powder bed fusion

The Impact of Additive Manufacturing in the Aircraft Spare Parts Supply Chain: Supply Chain Operation Reference (scor) Model Based Analysis

Design Approach for Additive Manufacturing in Spare Part Supply Chains

Environmental and Economic Implications of Distributed Additive Manufacturing: The Case of Injection Mold Tooling

Sustainability of Additive Manufacturing: an Overview on Its Energy Demand and Environmental Impact

A Decision-Support Model for Additive Manufacturing Scheduling Using an Integrative Analytic Hierarchy Process and Multi-Objective Optimization

Stock or Print? Impact of 3D Printing on Spare Parts Logistics

Production planning in additive manufacturing and 3D printing

A Multi-Part Production Planning System for a Distributed Network of 3D Printers under the Context of Social Manufacturing

A quantitative framework to support the decision between traditional, selective, and hybrid assembly

Case - Digitizing Spare Parts Supply Chain Via 3D Printing: an Operational Cost Analysis.

Planning offline inspection strategies in low-volume manufacturing processes

Additive Manufacturing Redesigning of Metallic Parts for High Precision Machines

Justification Framework for Adoption of Additive Manufacturing to Automotive Supply Chain: AHP Approach