Abstract:Background: Challenges to books are surging across the United States, and books that portray diverse human experiences are particularly targeted. Censorship has deleterious consequences, such as undermining children’s intellectual freedom and influencing educators’ book selections. In a climate of censorship, when educators face the realistic possibility of a challenge, diverse voices may be silenced, and real-world issues avoided. Despite the impact that book challenges have, the experiences of educators who have faced them are understudied. Purpose: This study investigates the self-reported experiences of seven educators who have been involved in book challenges within K–12 public schools within the United States. Its goal is to yield new insights about how educators perceive the experience of censorship and what resources they leverage as they defend children’s right to read. It is significant because the lessons learned from these educators may be instructive for novice and veteran teachers and school librarians who are facing censorship—an increasingly likely possibility in contemporary times. It also highlights the range of forms that censorship takes within today’s schools. Research Design: This research employs a collective case study design. Seven teachers and school librarians from K–12 public schools across the United States were interviewed about their experiences with book challenges and other forms of censorship. Interview transcripts were qualitatively analyzed using Pierre Bourdieu’s types of cultural capital as a framework. Within-case and cross-case analyses are presented. Conclusions: Participants drew from various forms of cultural capital in their efforts to defend children’s intellectual freedom, including their professional ethics, school policies, and institutional knowledge. The study emphasizes the importance of building cultural capital among pre- and in-service educators within university preparation and professional development programs. It also calls on professional groups within education and librarianship to take an organized stand against censorship.

The Gettysburg Address in English Class: An ‘Exemplar’ of Common Core’s Attack On Diverse Learners

Knowledge, Literacy, and the Common Core

Complicating canons: a critical literacy challenge to common core assessment

Media at the Core: How Media Literacy Strategies Strengthen Teaching with Common Core

Transformational Opportunities: Language and Literacy Instruction for English Language Learners in the Common Core Era in the United States

Beyond the Common Core: Examining 20 Years of Literacy Priorities and Their Impact on Struggling Readers

Examining Linguistics in the Language Strand of the Common Core State Standards

Writing to the Common Core: teachers’ responses to changes in standards and assessments for writing in elementary schools

Teachers’ Perceptions of the Implementation of the Literacy Common Core State Standards for English Language Learners and Students With Disabilities

Common Core Preparation in Special Education Teacher Education Programs

The Common Core State Standards and Reading: Interpretations and Implications for Elementary Students with Learning Disabilities

Responding to The Great Gatsby: Can the Reading Process Itself Reinforce Racist Assumptions?

“It’s Important for Them to Know Who They Are”: Teachers’ Efforts to Sustain Students’ Cultural Competence in an Age of High-Stakes Testing

Developing Understandings of Race: Preservice Teachers’ Counter-Narrative (Re)Constructions of People of Color in Young Adult Literature

Teaching that “Promotes Diversity”: The Potential of Disruptive Narratives

“It’s Bigger Than Just a Book Challenge”: A Collective Case Study of Educators’ Experiences With Censorship

Politics by Other Means: Civic Education in a Time of Controversy

Cultural Construction Zones

Disciplinary Literacy and the Common Core State Standards

How to Cultivate Students’ Core Literacy in the Unit Introduction Course? Take Middle School English as an Example

Pedagogies of Naming, Questioning, and Demystification: A Study of Two Critical U.S. History Classrooms