Spatial and temporal characterization of droplet diameter and velocities of a nasal spray atomization

James Van Strien,Sara Vahaji,Petros Lappas,David Morton,Kiao Inthavong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02786826.2024.2332633

2024-04-03

Aerosol Science and Technology

Abstract:Nasal sprays can deliver drugs topically to the nasal cavity and, alternatively, to the vascular system via the nasal epithelium, avoiding painful injections. The atomized spray characteristics can be optimally controlled for the desired parameters such as spray plume, cone angle, droplet velocity and droplet size distribution to target specific locations in the nasal cavity. These parameters have been investigated through computational simulations to evaluate the spray performance within the nasal cavity, however there is a lack of experimental measurements providing three-dimensional velocity data for nasal sprays. This study aims to address key elements of this gap using Phase Doppler Particle Analysis (PDPA) to measure both the droplet size and three-dimensional velocity from two over-the-counter nasal spray devices actuated with a pneumatic device delivering actuation forces equivalent to averaged pediatric, adult, and a maximum adult exertion. In addition to providing experimental data for verifying CFD simulations, this study provides multiple, and some unique, presentations of characterizing the nasal spray velocity and size behavior. Multiple new conclusions were drawn from this study, including a demonstration that the spray droplet axial velocity is the dominant velocity component, followed by radial velocity. Tangential velocity exists but is negligible by comparison. Finer droplets tended to move slower and were predominantly found in the spray core (although this may not be the case with a fluid of higher viscosity). Larger, faster droplets are found near the spray's edge in the pressure-swirl nasal sprays. The mean resultant velocity between both devices at 15 mm from the nozzle tip, actuated at the mean adult force was 16.9 m/s. The mean D32 and Dv50 of both devices at the mean adult actuation force was 23.0 μm and 80.0 μm , respectively.

environmental sciences,meteorology & atmospheric sciences,engineering, chemical, mechanical

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the detailed measurement of droplet diameter and velocity characteristics of nasal sprays in both spatial and temporal dimensions. Specifically, the study aims to fill the gap in existing experimental data by measuring the droplet diameter and 3D velocity of two commercially available nasal sprays under different force conditions using Phase Doppler Particle Analysis (PDPA) technology.

### Background and Problem
Nasal sprays can deliver medication directly to the nasal cavity or through the nasal mucosa into the vascular system, avoiding the pain of injections. To achieve effective deposition of the drug at specific locations in the nasal cavity, precise control of spray characteristics is required, including spray cone angle, dispersion angle, droplet velocity, and droplet size distribution. Although Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) simulations have evaluated these parameters' performance within the nasal cavity, there is a lack of experimental measurements providing 3D velocity data for nasal sprays.

### Research Objectives
1. **Provide Experimental Data**: Using PDPA technology, provide experimental data on droplet diameter and 3D velocity of nasal sprays under different force conditions to validate CFD simulation results.
2. **Fill Data Gaps**: Most existing PDPA studies have only measured axial velocity, while this study aims to provide comprehensive 3D velocity data.
3. **Optimize Spray Performance**: Detailed measurements of droplet behavior will provide scientific evidence for optimizing the design and use of nasal sprays.

### Main Findings
- **Dominance of Axial Velocity**: The axial velocity of spray droplets is the primary velocity component, followed by radial velocity, with tangential velocity being relatively small.
- **Relationship Between Droplet Size and Velocity**: Smaller droplets typically move slower and are mainly concentrated in the core region of the spray; larger droplets are located at the spray edges and move faster.
- **Effect of Force**: Increasing the force leads to an increase in droplet velocity and a decrease in droplet size, consistent with previous theories.

### Conclusion
Using PDPA technology, the study successfully measured the droplet diameter and 3D velocity of nasal sprays under different force conditions, providing important experimental data for the design and optimization of nasal sprays. These data not only validate existing CFD simulation results but also offer new perspectives for future related research.