Abstract:Debate has been warranted as a meaningful activity to promote students' higher-level thinking, such as critical thinking. However, traditional debate activities which are typically carried out in the physical classroom may meet some obstructions of limited time and space, which would result in the phenomenon that many participants act as silent watchers rather than mind exchangers. Moreover, it is hard to make a visualized record about the whole process and contents of the traditional debate activity. The current study aimed to explore the effects of argument map (AM)-supported online group debate activities on college students' critical thinking, including their depth and phases of critical thinking, and the relationship between students' depth of critical thinking and their number of speeches. In the study, an innovative argumentation construction way was designed. All students enrolled in a course could have a chance to attend the AM-supported online group debate activities and the whole process and outcomes of online group debate could be visualized by AM. At the same time, the effectiveness of the innovative activities was evaluated by content analysis of AM. A total of 42 sophomores in the undergraduate course named "Learning Sciences and Technology" were recruited to attend online group debate activities assisted by a web-based visualization tool named "ZJU Yuque" in 5 weeks. Newman's framework about the depth of critical thinking and Murthy's instrument of critical thinking phases were employed as guidelines. We found that 42 students' overall depth of critical thinking was gradually improved in an obvious way during the five online debate activities. The most frequent phases for students in the first and second team in online group debate activities include Understand -> Understand (U -> U), Recognize -> Understand (R -> U), and Understand -> Evaluate (U -> E). However, students' creating behaviors were not significantly generated. Teachers' real-time feedback was helpful for students' improvements of high-level thinking skills and their preparation for the next debate activity. Students' interviews found that students highly valued such online group debate activities because every student could have a chance to express their thoughts and they had enough time to prepare debate contents. Based on the findings, some implications were proposed for the better design and implementation of online group debate activities.

Interactive learning environment as a source of critical thinking skills for college students

Exploring the Effects of Argument Map-Supported Online Group Debate Activities on College Students' Critical Thinking

Exploring College Students’ Depth and Processing Patterns of Critical Thinking Skills and Their Perception in Argument Map(am)-Supported Online Group Debate Activities

Exploring Debaters and Audiences' Depth of Critical Thinking and Its Relationship with Their Participation in Debate Activities

Interactive environment for music education: developing certain thinking skills in a mobile or static interactive environment

Improving critical thinking skills of high school students through the implementation of mobile-based game applications

Examining the relationships between students’ perceptions of technology, pedagogy, and cognition: the case of immersive virtual reality mini games to foster computational thinking in higher education

Improving moral reasoning among college students: a game-based learning approach

Learning Through Action: Creating and Implementing a Strategy Game to Foster Innovative Thinking in Higher Education

The Research on Critical Thinking Teaching Strategies in College English Classroom

Enhancing L2 Learners’ Critical Thinking Skills Through a Connectivism-Based Intelligent Learning System

A digital role-playing game for learning: effects on critical thinking and motivation

Cracking the code: using educational gaming for high-level thinking in physiology education

Playing with AI to Investigate Human-Computer Interaction Technology and Improving Critical Thinking Skills to Pursue 21st Century Age

The cultivation of critical thinking skills of college students in English classroom

Learning model based on discovery learning equipped with interactive multimedia teaching materials assisted by games to improve critical thinking skills of high school students

Fostering Critical Thinking Skills in Chinese University Students through the Superstar Learning Platform

Computer teaching process optimization strategy analysis of thinking ability

Exploration of Happy Learning for College Students with the Integration of Thinking Visualization and Action Learning in the Internet + Environment

Implementation and Evaluation of a Virtual Reality-Based Cognitive Assessment and Rehabilitation Simulation Course in Undergraduate Nursing Students: A Pre-Post Study