Abstract:In all experimental sciences, the precision and reliability of quantitative measurements are paramount. This is particularly true when examining the interactions between small molecules and biomolecules/polyelectrolytes, such as DNAs/RNAs, and yet it is overlooked in most publications of thermodynamic binding parameters. This paper presents findings from COST Action 18202 "Network for Equilibria and Chemical Thermodynamics Advanced Research," which assessed the consistency of data derived from the interactions of calf-thymus DNA (CT-DNA) with the fluorescent intercalator ethidium bromide (EB) through spectrofluorimetric titrations. We first discuss critical experimental aspects and propose a reference experimental protocol which can be used to calibrate procedures for the determination of nucleic acid binding equilibrium constants. We then fit the experimental points according to different procedures and analyse the results focusing on the statistical dispersion of the data, aiming at enlightening the strong and weak points of different fitting procedures. The implications of this work are significant, demonstrating how the statistical dispersion of experimental data can influence the interpretation of biochemical coordination mechanisms. Our study reveals that, despite rigorous protocol standardization, the determination of binding parameters remains sensitive to the choice of data fitting method, with deviations in the logarithmic stability constant (log K ) values not falling below 5 % relative standard deviation (RSD), or ± 0.5 log K units for 95 % confidence. This variability evidences the critical need for standardized best practices in data treatment as well as experimental procedures. Although our study focuses on the EB/CT-DNA system through fluorescence titrations, the broader implications for other methodologies across various biochemical systems highlight the importance of this first-of-its-kind inter-laboratory comparison in advancing our understanding of biochemical coordination processes.

Fundamental Determinants of the Accuracy of Equilibrium Constants for Affinity Complexes

Introducing Quantitative Assessment of Accuracy for the Equilibrium Constant of Affinity Complexes

ABC of Kd Accuracy

Biomolecular conformational changes and ligand binding: from kinetics to thermodynamics.

Optimal experimental design for precise parameter estimation in competitive cross-reaction equilibria

Simple Determination of Affinity Constants of Antibodies by Competitive Immunoassays

Interplay Between Binding Affinity and Kinetics in Protein–protein Interactions

Equilibrium and Non-equilibrium Ensemble Methods for Accurate, Precise and Reproducible Absolute Binding Free Energy Calculations

The accuracy of biochemical interactions is ensured by endothermic stepwise kinetics

Dynamics and Thermodynamics of Ligand–Protein Interactions

On achieving high accuracy and reliability in the calculation of relative protein–ligand binding affinities

Does a More Precise Chemical Description of Protein–Ligand Complexes Lead to More Accurate Prediction of Binding Affinity?

Rigorous Free Energy Perturbation Approach to Estimating Relative Binding Affinities Between Ligands with Multiple Protonation and Tautomeric States.

Validation of the Alchemical Transfer Method for the Estimation of Relative Binding Affinities of Molecular Series

Learning from Classic: DNA-Based Conditional Equilibrium Constant To Regulate Affinity "On-the-Fly" for Bioassays

Validity and Reliability of Benesi-Hildebrand Method

A Statistical Survey on the Binding Constants of Covalently Bound Protein-Ligand Complexes

Estimation of Binding Constants of Receptors and Ligands by Affinity Capillary Electrophoresis.

An energy interconversion principle applied in reaction dynamics for the determination of equilibrium standard states

How reliable is the evaluation of DNA binding constants? Insights and best practices based on an inter-laboratory fluorescence titration study

The form of the rate constant for elementary reactions at equilibrium from MD: framework and proposals for thermokinetics