Abstract:Accurate specification of spatiotemporal errors of remotely sensed soil moisture (SM) data is essential for a correct assessment of their utility and optimally integrating multiple SM products or assimilating them into hydrological models. Although Triple Collocation Analysis (TCA) has been widely used to provide SM errors, the impact of rescaling technique on the TCA error estimates has not received major attention, which can lead to biased and inaccurate error estimates. Moreover, current knowledge about time-variant SM errors derived from TCA is still very limited, which hampers the advance of applying time-variant errors in data merging and data assimilation studies efficiently. Based on these considerations, this work aims to advance the use of the TCA for characterizing errors with a focus on the rescaling techniques, and validating TCA-based time-variant errors using global ground measurements in 759 grid cells. To this end, the Advanced Scatterometer (ASCAT) and four passive-based SM products, including Soil Moisture and Ocean Salinity Level-3 (SMOS-L3), SMOS INRA-CESBIO (SMOS-IC), Soil Moisture Active Passive Level-3 (SMAP-L3), and SMAP INRAE BORDEAUX (SMAP-IB) SM products, were considered. The time-variant error term here denotes an aggregate error magnitude over a 101-day moving-time-window. It is found that different selection of the rescaling technique considered in TCA led to TCA error estimates with significantly different accuracy when ground-based errors are regarded as the benchmark. The optimal combination strategy to implement TCA is applying TCA to SM anomalies and rescaling the errors by coefficients derived from the TCA model. Pearson's correlation with ground-based time-variant errors is 0.62, 0.72, 0.83, 0.89, and 0.93 for SMAP-IB, SMAP-L3, SMOS-IC, SMOS-L3, and ASCAT SM, respectively. Considering time-variant errors in applications is necessary since time-variant errors deviate from time-invariant errors by 50% when errors are rescaled by the TCA model parameters. Time-invariant errors are greater than time-variant errors when SM products are rescaled against a reference dataset while the opposite conclusion can be drawn when errors are rescaled by the TCA coefficients. TCA- and ground-based methods provide consistent evaluations in 74.7% (77.3%), 75.8% (79.8%), 79.6% (81.1%), and 78.6% (79.7%) of the analysis period on average (median) for the TCA implementations with SMAP-L3, SMAP-IB, SMOS-L3, and SMOS-IC SM, respectively. The error analysis reveals that TCA typically underestimated ASCAT errors while overestimated passive SM errors when considering ground-based evaluation as the benchmark. Moreover, TCA was found to have relatively less power to efficiently characterize SM errors in croplands when compared with other land cover types. This study validated TCA time-variant errors using ground measurements and compared TCA- and ground-based evaluation performances on a global scale. Our work arouses particular attention to the rescaling technique selection considered in TCA, which is crucial for accurately characterizing SM errors and efficiently using them in various hydrometeorological applications.

Vegetation signal crosstalk present in official SMAP surface soil moisture retrievals

Soil Moisture Retrievals By Combining Passive Microwave And Optical Data

SMAP Underestimates Soil Moisture in Vegetation-Disturbed Areas Primarily As a Result of Biased Surface Temperature Data

SMAP-based retrieval of vegetation opacity and albedo

A New SMAP Soil Moisture and Vegetation Optical Depth Product (SMAP-IB): Algorithm, Assessment and Inter-Comparison

Mapping High Spatiotemporal-Resolution Soil Moisture by Upscaling Sparse Ground-Based Observations Using a Bayesian Linear Regression Method for Comparison with Microwave Remotely Sensed Soil Moisture Products

Assessment of five SMAP soil moisture products using ISMN ground-based measurements over varied environmental conditions

Integration of Sentinel-1A Radar and SMAP Radiometer for Soil Moisture Retrieval over Vegetated Areas

A global-scale intercomparison of Triple Collocation Analysis- and ground-based soil moisture time-variant errors derived from different rescaling techniques

Characterizing the Accuracy of Satellite-Based Products to Detect Soil Moisture at the Global Scale

Global-Scale Assessment of Multiple Recently Developed/Reprocessed Remotely Sensed Soil Moisture Datasets

Inverse Dynamic Parameter Identification for Remote Sensing of Soil Moisture From SMAP Satellite Observations

First Mapping of Polarization-Dependent Vegetation Optical Depth and Soil Moisture from SMAP L-band Radiometry

Validation of Soil Moisture Data Products From the NASA SMAP Mission

Remote sensing of vegetation dynamics in agro-ecosystems using SMAP vegetation optical depth and optical vegetation indices

Enhancing Soil Moisture Active–Passive Estimates with Soil Moisture Active–Passive Reflectometer Data Using Graph Signal Processing

Surface soil moisture from combined active and passive microwave observations: Integrating ASCAT and SMAP observations based on machine learning approaches

Estimating Surface Soil Moisture from AMSR2 TB with Machine Learning Methods and SMAP Products

A New Soil Moisture Retrieval Algorithm from the L-Band Passive Microwave Brightness Temperature Based on the Change Detection Principle

A Novel Scheme for Merging Active and Passive Satellite Soil Moisture Retrievals Based on Maximizing the Signal to Noise Ratio

Soil Moisture Retrieval over a Vegetation-Covered Area Using ALOS-2 L-Band Synthetic Aperture Radar Data