Abstract:BACKGROUND:Randomized controlled trials are considered the gold standard for evaluating experimental treatments but often require large sample sizes. Single-arm trials require smaller sample sizes but are subject to bias when using historical control data for comparative inferences. This article presents a Bayesian adaptive synthetic-control design that exploits historical control data to create a hybrid of a single-arm trial and a randomized controlled trial.METHODS:The Bayesian adaptive synthetic control design has two stages. In stage 1, a prespecified number of patients are enrolled in a single arm given the experimental treatment. Based on the stage 1 data, applying propensity score matching and Bayesian posterior prediction methods, the usefulness of the historical control data for identifying a pseudo sample of matched synthetic-control patients for making comparative inferences is evaluated. If a sufficient number of synthetic controls can be identified, the single-arm trial is continued. If not, the trial is switched to a randomized controlled trial. The performance of The Bayesian adaptive synthetic control design is evaluated by computer simulation.RESULTS:The Bayesian adaptive synthetic control design achieves power and unbiasedness similar to a randomized controlled trial but on average requires a much smaller sample size, provided that the historical control data patients are sufficiently comparable to the trial patients so that a good number of matched controls can be identified in the historical control data. Compared to a single-arm trial, The Bayesian adaptive synthetic control design yields much higher power and much smaller bias.CONCLUSION:The Bayesian adaptive synthetic-control design provides a useful tool for exploiting historical control data to improve the efficiency of single-arm phase II clinical trials, while addressing the problem of bias when comparing trial results to historical control data. The proposed design achieves power similar to a randomized controlled trial but may require a substantially smaller sample size.

Potential Bias Models With Bayesian Shrinkage Priors for Dynamic Borrowing of Multiple Historical Control Data

Dynamic borrowing from historical controls via the synthetic prior with covariates in randomized clinical trials

Elastic Meta-Analytic-predictive Prior for Dynamically Borrowing Information from Historical Data with Application to Biosimilar Clinical Trials.

Propensity score-integrated Bayesian prior approaches for augmented control designs: a simulation study

Deep historical borrowing framework to prospectively and simultaneously synthesize control information in confirmatory clinical trials with multiple endpoints

Dynamic borrowing of historical controls adjusting for covariates in vaccine efficacy clinical trials

Bias correction for multiple covariate analysis using empirical bayesian estimation in mixed-effects models for longitudinal data

A unified Bayesian framework for bias adjustment in multiple comparisons from clinical trials

BASIC: A Bayesian Adaptive Synthetic-Control Design for Phase II Clinical Trials.

Adaptive Hybrid Control Design for Comparative Clinical Trials with Historical Control Data

Elastic Priors to Dynamically Borrow Information from Historical Data in Clinical Trials

A Calibrated Power Prior Approach to Borrow Information from Historical Data with Application to Biosimilar Clinical Trials.

Bayesian Variable Selection for Mixed Effects Model with Shrinkage Prior.

A scaled kernel density estimation prior for dynamic borrowing of historical information with application to clinical trial design

Borrowing historical information to improve phase I clinical trials using meta-analytic-predictive priors

A Quantitative Bias Analysis to Assess Constancy Assumption in Noninferiority Trials Using Bayesian Hierarchical Models

Case weighted power priors for hybrid control analyses with time-to-event data

Power Priors Based on Multiple Historical Studies for Binary Outcomes

High-dimensional confounding adjustment using continuous spike and slab priors

Digital twins and Bayesian dynamic borrowing: Two recent approaches for incorporating historical control data

Robust incorporation of historical information with known type I error rate inflation