Biodegradable metals for bone defect repair: A systematic review and meta-analysis based on animal studies

Jiazhen Zhang,Yanbiao Jiang,Zhizhong Shang,Bing Zhao,Mingyue Jiao,Wenbo Liu,Maobo Cheng,Bao Zhai,Yajuan Guo,Bin Liu,Xinli Shi,Bin Ma
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bioactmat.2021.03.035
IF: 18.9
2021-11-01
Bioactive Materials
Abstract:The first systematic review &amp; meta-analysis on biodegradable metals.The quality of evidence of biodegradable metals for bone defect repair is very low.Evidence-based study is an effective approach for biomaterials research.Biodegradable metals are promising candidates for bone defect repair. With an evidence-based approach, this study investigated and analyzed the performance and degradation properties of biodegradable metals in animal models for bone defect repair to explore their potential clinical translation. Animal studies on bone defect repair with biodegradable metals in comparison with other traditional biomaterials were reviewed. Data was carefully collected after identification of population, intervention, comparison, outcome, and study design (PICOS), and following the inclusion criteria of biodegradable metals in animal studies. 30 publications on pure Mg, Mg alloys, pure Zn and Zn alloys were finally included after extraction from a collected database of 2543 publications. A qualitative systematic review and a quantitative meta-analysis were performed. Given the heterogeneity in animal model, anatomical site and critical size defect (CSD), biodegradable metals exhibited mixed effects on bone defect repair and degradation in animal studies in comparison with traditional non-degradable metals, biodegradable polymers, bioceramics, and autogenous bone grafts. The results indicated that there were limitations in the experimental design of the included studies, and quality of the evidence presented by the studies was very low. To enhance clinical translation of biodegradable metals, evidence-based research with data validity is needed. Future studies should adopt standardized experimental protocols in investigating the effects of biodegradable metals on bone defect repair with animal models.<span class="display"><span><ol class="links-for-figure"><li><a class="anchor download-link u-font-sans" href="https://ars.els-cdn.com/content/image/1-s2.0-S2452199X21001468-ga1_lrg.jpg"><span class="anchor-text">Download : <span class="download-link-title">Download high-res image (278KB)</span></span></a></li><li><a class="anchor download-link u-font-sans" href="https://ars.els-cdn.com/content/image/1-s2.0-S2452199X21001468-ga1.jpg"><span class="anchor-text">Download : <span class="download-link-title">Download full-size image</span></span></a></li></ol></span></span>
engineering, biomedical,materials science, biomaterials
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to address the selection and effectiveness evaluation of bone defect repair materials. Specifically, the study explores the performance and degradation characteristics of biodegradable metals used in animal experiments for bone defect repair through systematic review and meta-analysis, in order to explore their potential clinical application value. The study compares the effects of biodegradable metals with other traditional biomaterials (such as non-degradable metals, biodegradable polymers, bioceramics, and autografts or allografts) and points out the limitations in design and low quality of evidence in existing studies. To enhance the clinical application of biodegradable metals, evidence-based research is needed, and the validity of the data must be ensured. Future research should adopt standardized experimental protocols to further verify the effectiveness of biodegradable metals in bone defect repair.