Abstract:Introduction: The optimal management for patients with small, low-risk thyroid cancer is often debated. We aimed to characterize the attitudes and beliefs of providers and patients about management of small, low-risk thyroid cancer and how they relate to overtreatment. Methods: We conducted 34 semi-structured interviews with surgeons (n = 12), endocrinologists (n = 12), and patients with <1.5 cm papillary thyroid cancer (n = 10). Interviews probed about diagnosis and treatment decision-making, including nonoperative options. We used thematic analysis to identify themes related to overtreatment and created concept diagrams to map observed relationships between themes. Results: When providers discussed management of small, low-risk thyroid cancer, most felt that overtreatment was a problem, and some brought it up without prompting. Providers often believed that overtreatment results from overdiagnosis and relayed how the process commonly starts with incidental discovery of a thyroid nodule on imaging. Providers viewed biopsy of the nodule as a reflexive or habitual action. They ascribed inappropriate biopsy to lack of adherence to or knowledge of guidelines, radiologist recommendations, and the desire of patients and physicians to minimize diagnostic uncertainty. Providers described subsequent cancer diagnosis as an event that "opens Pandora's box" and often provokes a strong instinctive, culturally rooted need to proceed with surgery-specifically total thyroidectomy. Consequently, most providers felt that it is easier to prevent overdiagnosis than overtreatment and recommended strategies such as improving guideline adherence, resetting patients' expectations, and engaging the media. In contrast, patients did not bring up or openly discuss overtreatment or overdiagnosis. Some patients described the seemingly automatic process from an incidental finding to surgery. Their statements confirmed that the "need to know" was a major motivation for biopsying their nodule. Patients felt that once they had a cancer diagnosis, surgery was a foregone conclusion. Patients admitted their knowledge about thyroid nodules and cancer was low, leaving room for education about the need for biopsy and less extensive treatment options. Conclusions: Surgeons' and endocrinologists' attitudes and beliefs about overtreatment focus on the automaticity of overdiagnosis. Both patients and providers are cognizant of the cascade of clinical events that propel patients from incidental discovery of a thyroid nodule to surgery.

Evolution in the management of thyroid surgery over a period of 15 years in a Belgian center

Partial Versus Total Thyroidectomy: What Influences Most Surgeons' Decision? Analysis of a Nationwide Cohort of 375,810 Patients Over 10 Years

Changing trends in thyroidectomy

Clinicopathological and Prognostic Analysis of Follicular Thyroid Carcinoma in a Single Institute over a 15-Year Period

Endocrine surgeons are performing more thyroid lobectomies for low-risk differentiated thyroid cancer since the 2015 ATA guidelines

Summary and update on the management of differentiated thyroid cancer in 2023

Diagnosing and management of thyroid nodules and goiter - current perspectives

Transition Analysis in the Clinicopathology and Prognosis of 2 682 Papillary Thyroid Carcinoma Cases over a 15-Year Period

Thyroid surgery for differentiated thyroid cancer - recent advances and future directions

Temporal and Geographical Variations of Thyroid Cancer Incidence and Mortality in France During 1986-2015: the Impact of Overdiagnosis

THYROID SURGERY INDICATIONS: TO WHAT EXTENT IS THE ULTRASOUND RISK-STRATIFICATION OF THYROID NODULES PERFORMED IN CLINICAL SETTING?

Evolutionary analysis of indeterminate cytology and risk of malignancy in a thyroid nodule unit.

Results of thyroidectomies according to general surgeons and otolaryngologist and cervico faciale surgeons at the general Hospital of Reference of Niamey, what differences in the protocols of management?

Effects of Implementation of European Thyroid Imaging Reporting and Data System Risk Stratification in a Thyroid Cancer Program in Western Sweden: A Retrospective Cohort Study

Surgical treatment of metastasis to the thyroid gland: a single center experience and literature review

Current practice in patients with differentiated thyroid cancer

From Overdiagnosis to Overtreatment of Low-Risk Thyroid Cancer: A Thematic Analysis of Attitudes and Beliefs of Endocrinologists, Surgeons, and Patients

Management of Incidental Thyroid Nodules in the Pretransplant Population

Surgical management of Graves' disease: historical context and single institution experience

Global trends in research of endoscopic thyroidectomy from 2013 to 2022: a scientometric and visualization analysis

Management of Thyroglossal Duct Cysts in Children: Retrospective Analysis of a Series of 32 Patients