Exploring the violent enforcement stereotype of Chengguan: a qualitative study in China

Yutong Pan,Yujiao Feng,Yan Liu,Jinfa Liu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12144-024-06444-0
IF: 2.8
2024-08-19
Current Psychology
Abstract:This study aimed to investigate the reasons of the violent enforcement stereotype of Chengguan. To achieve this objective, 55 semi-structured qualitative interviews were conducted with street vendors, Chengguan staff and the public in 2022 and 2023. The analysis drew upon street-level bureaucracy theory and employed inductive content analysis to thoroughly examine the interview data. The research revealed that the public commonly associates Chengguan with violent enforcement, mainly due to a pattern of violent tendencies and behaviors observed in specific enforcement actions. A deeper analysis indicated that the ambiguous positioning of Chengguan department, the low thresholds of staff recruitment, and the perfunctory accountability of staff dismissal are the root reasons for violent enforcement by Chengguan. Additionally, the negative portrayal of Chengguan in self-media and the reduced effectiveness of traditional authoritative media in conveying objective information have both shaped and entrenched this negative image. This paper extends the application of street-level bureaucracy theory, offering a new perspective and analytical framework to better understand the stereotype of violent enforcement by Chengguan. Moreover, the study presents practical strategies to address or mitigate the negative stereotype. To our knowledge, this work represents a comprehensive and systematic theoretical discussion on the stereotype of violent enforcement by Chengguan, providing significant theoretical insights and practical relevance.
psychology, multidisciplinary
What problem does this paper attempt to address?