Abstract:Abstract Background Risk prediction models for time-to-event outcomes play a vital role in personalized decision-making. A patient’s biomarker values, such as medical lab results, are often measured over time but traditional prediction models ignore their longitudinal nature, using only baseline information. Dynamic prediction incorporates longitudinal information to produce updated survival predictions during follow-up. Existing methods for dynamic prediction include joint modeling, which often suffers from computational complexity and poor performance under misspecification, and landmarking, which has a straightforward implementation but typically relies on a proportional hazards model. Random survival forests (RSF), a machine learning algorithm for time-to-event outcomes, can capture complex relationships between the predictors and survival without requiring prior specification and has been shown to have superior predictive performance. Methods We propose an alternative approach for dynamic prediction using random survival forests in a landmarking framework. With a simulation study, we compared the predictive performance of our proposed method with Cox landmarking and joint modeling in situations where the proportional hazards assumption does not hold and the longitudinal marker(s) have a complex relationship with the survival outcome. We illustrated the use of the RSF landmark approach in two clinical applications to assess the performance of various RSF model building decisions and to demonstrate its use in obtaining dynamic predictions. Results In simulation studies, RSF landmarking outperformed joint modeling and Cox landmarking when a complex relationship between the survival and longitudinal marker processes was present. It was also useful in application when there were several predictors for which the clinical relevance was unknown and multiple longitudinal biomarkers were present. Individualized dynamic predictions can be obtained from this method and the variable importance metric is useful for examining the changing predictive power of variables over time. In addition, RSF landmarking is easily implementable in standard software and using suggested specifications requires less computation time than joint modeling. Conclusions RSF landmarking is a nonparametric, machine learning alternative to current methods for obtaining dynamic predictions when there are complex or unknown relationships present. It requires little upfront decision-making and has comparable predictive performance and has preferable computational speed.

pencal: an R Package for the Dynamic Prediction of Survival with Many Longitudinal Predictors

Penalized regression calibration: a method for the prediction of survival outcomes using complex longitudinal and high-dimensional data

Unbiased Prediction and Feature Selection in High-Dimensional Survival Regression

Tutorial in Joint Modeling and Prediction: a Statistical Software for Correlated Longitudinal Outcomes, Recurrent Events and a Terminal Event

Parmsurv: a SAS Macro for Flexible Parametric Survival Analysis with Long-Term Predictions

Dynamic prediction of survival using multivariate functional principal component analysis: A strict landmarking approach

Random survival forests for dynamic predictions of a time-to-event outcome using a longitudinal biomarker

Improved dynamic predictions from joint models of longitudinal and survival data with time-varying effects using P-splines

Delayed kernels for longitudinal survival analysis and dynamic prediction

Multi-stage optimal dynamic treatment regimes for survival outcomes with dependent censoring

Dynamic Prediction of Competing Risk Events using Landmark Sub-distribution Hazard Model with Multiple Longitudinal Biomarker

Multilevel mixed effects parametric survival models using adaptive Gauss-Hermite quadrature with application to recurrent events and individual participant data meta-analysis

PWEXP: An R Package Using Piecewise Exponential Model for Study Design and Event/Timeline Prediction

survextrap: a package for flexible and transparent survival extrapolation

Multi-Parameter Regression Survival Modelling: An Alternative to Proportional Hazards

Random survival forests with multivariate longitudinal endogenous covariates

Dynamic updating of clinical survival prediction models in a changing environment

Review for Dynamic Prediction in Clinical Survival Analysis

Individualized survival predictions using state space model with longitudinal and survival data

A tutorial on evaluating time-varying discrimination accuracy for survival models used in dynamic decision-making

Penalized Bayesian forward continuation ratio model with application to high-dimensional data with discrete survival outcomes