The Scrapyard and the Archive: A Comment on Grossmark's "The Untelling"

Dominique Scarfone
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10481885.2023.2290278
2024-03-07
Psychoanalytic Dialogues
Abstract:Robert Grossmark's "The Untelling" is an original contribution to the understanding of the psychoanalytic process, especially with the introduction of the notions of Untelling and of Filled-in and Hollowed-out enactments. This comment aims at favoring further exchanges with Grossmark, especially on the problem of meaning in relation to enactment and the importance of the time dimension in the changes that psychoanalysis can bring about. It is, namely, a matter of creating the category of the past. The metaphor of a scrapyard and the dangerous sharp objects it contains is used in relation to the clinical case. The metaphor illustrates how what is brought back through enactment into the analytic process does not carry in itself a fixed meaning, but can be given a workable meaning through handling the transference while ensuring both the reliability of the analytic frame and the analyst's own passibility .
psychology, psychoanalysis
What problem does this paper attempt to address?