Menstruation as the Next Vital Sign

Lauren C. Houghton

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2024.12778

2024-05-30

JAMA Network Open

Abstract:Age at menarche (an individual's first period) and menstrual cycle regularity are 2 reproductive factors that reflect the overall health of a population. Wang et al 1 examined trends in age at menarche and time to cycle regularity in a large digital US cohort spanning 55 years and report decreasing age at menarche and longer intervals to regular cycles, indicating worsening health outcomes over time. The authors examined these trends in a cohort that is more racially and ethnically diverse than previous studies. Although the sample is not representative of the overall distribution of race and ethnicity in the US, the authors found that menarche was earlier and time to regularity was longer in Black participants, Asian participants, Hispanic participants, and those of other or multiple races than White participants. Every couple of years, concerns around the decreasing age at puberty arise in the news, often fueled by new evidence published in academic journals. 2 ,3 Age at puberty is a bioassay of population health at the mass scale. In general, countries with a mean age of menarche above 12 years reflect populations facing undernutrition and higher infectious disease burden; countries with ages younger than 12 years reflect populations with overnutrition and higher risk for chronic diseases. The US is an example of the latter, and the decreasing age of menarche points to possible increases in chronic diseases, including mental health, cardiovascular disease, and breast cancer. Age at menarche is associated with menstrual cycle regularity, which is an indicator that some suggest could be used as the next vital sign. 4 Just as clinicians regularly check blood pressure, they should also inquire about menstrual health, including last menstrual period, cycle length and regularity, and associated symptoms that occur around menstruation. Menstrual cycle characteristics outside clinical norms or changes over time for an individual may be a warning sign of underlying risk and pathology. This most recent investigation into trends in menarche and time to menstrual cycle regularity is an important, overdue update. Former studies that established norms for cycle characteristics are outdated because they were published in the 1960s and rely on cohorts of women who started tracking their cycles in the 1930s. 5 Later, in the 1980s, Apter and Vihko, 6 working with female individuals born in the 1960s, found earlier age at menarche, which led to faster time to cycle regularity than in female individuals with older ages at menarche. Since the 1960s, there have been no US-based studies specifically linking age at menarche with cycle regularity. With the advent of menstrual cycle tracking applications (apps) on smart phones, researchers have described menstrual cycle characteristics among app users, confirming what analog data (postcards with menstrual dates) first suggested—that between-individual variation is the norm. Wang et al 1 also used the strengths of app data specifically to describe menarche and time to cycle regularity and have integrated it with demographic and anthropometric data collected through cohort design to fill in the trends since the 1960s. The authors argue that obesity may explain the decreasing trend in age at menarche. Although body mass index (BMI) explains 46% of the decreasing age at menarche in their analysis, 1 there is a growing body of literature that pinpoints growth trajectories during different windows (eg, infancy and childhood adiposity rebound) as important. Wang et al 1 used recalled body size at menarche, which is a proxy of body size before the onset of puberty. Because pubertal timing and BMI may share a common pathway, especially when measured at the same time, the mediation analysis is not comparable to analysis conducted with longitudinal data and may overestimate the percentage of mediation. Moreover, growth and obesity are not the only factors responsible for decreases in menarche age. The authors note that decreases occurred before the population increase in obesity rates, indicating that the common narrative that obesity is the driving factor is too simplistic. During the COVID-19 pandemic, when stay-at-home mandates forced children to be less physically active and social media memes of baking bread at home suggested possible shifts in diet to more comforting caloric-dense foods, the media returned to concerns about decreasing ages of puberty for children coming of age during the pandemic. 7 Simultaneously, anecdotal reports of menstrual cycle disruption led to investigations into the possible links among COVID-19, vaccination, and changes to menstrual characteristics. A subsequent report, 8 also using menstrual tracking app data, concluded that vaccines administered during the follicular phase extended menstrual cycle -Abstract Truncated-

medicine, general & internal

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on the following aspects:

1. **Trends in the age of menarche**: By analyzing a large - scale US digital cohort data spanning 55 years, researchers explored the trends in the age of menarche (i.e., the first menstruation) of individuals born between 1950 and 2005. The study found that the age of menarche is gradually decreasing, which may reflect certain changes in the health status of the population.

2. **Changes in the regularity of the menstrual cycle**: In addition to the age of menarche, the study also focused on the time interval from menarche to a regular menstrual cycle and found that this time interval is lengthening, which may also indicate a deterioration of health outcomes.

3. **Racial and ethnic differences**: The study specifically examined the differences in the age of menarche and the regularity of the menstrual cycle among women with different racial and ethnic backgrounds. The results showed that black, Asian, Hispanic, and other or multi - racial - background women have an earlier age of menarche and a longer time required to reach a regular menstrual cycle compared to white women.

4. **The impact of obesity**: The study explored the potential impact of obesity on the downward trend in the age of menarche. Although the study pointed out that the body mass index (BMI) accounts for 46% of the decrease in the age of menarche, the authors also mentioned that obesity is not the only influencing factor, and the importance of growth trajectories in different windows (such as fat rebound in infancy and childhood) cannot be ignored.

5. **The public health significance of menstrual health**: The article emphasizes the importance of menstrual health as the next vital sign and recommends that clinicians include relevant inquiries about menstrual health in routine examinations to better assess an individual's health status. If the characteristics of the menstrual cycle deviate from clinical norms or change over time, they may be early - warning signs of potential health risks.

In summary, this paper aims to analyze a large amount of data to reveal the trends in the age of menarche and the regularity of the menstrual cycle as well as the underlying health and social factors, providing a scientific basis for public health policies and clinical practice.