Exclusive oral antibiotic treatment for hospitalized community-acquired pneumonia: a post-hoc analysis of a randomized clinical trial
Aurélien Dinh,Clara Duran,Jacques Ropers,Frédérique Bouchand,Laurène Deconinck,Morgan Matt,Olivia Senard,Aurore Lagrange,Guillaume Mellon,Ruxandra Calin,Sabrina Makhloufi,Victoire de Lastours,Emmanuel Mathieu,Jean-Emmanuel Kahn,Elisabeth Rouveix,Julie Grenet,Jennifer Dumoulin,Thierry Chinet,Marion Pépin,Véronique Delcey,Sylvain Diamantis,Daniel Benhamou,Virginie Vitrat,Marie-Christine Dombret,Bertrand Renaud,Yann-Erick Claessens,José Labarère,Jean-Pierre Bedos,Philippe Aegerter,Anne-Claude Crémieux,Pneumonia short treatment (PTC) study group,Julie Attal-Behar,Sébastien Beaune,Tristan Cudennec,Marine de Laroche,Albane de Thezy,Caroline Dupont,Elise Fercot,Violaine Giraut,Ségolène Greffe,Caroline Guyot,Sylvie Labrune,Marie Lachatre,Sophie Moulias,Charlotte Naline,Marine Sahut-D'izarn,Abel Sefssafi,Laurent Teillet,Jean-Pierre Bru,Jacques Gaillat,Vincent Gautier,Cécile Janssen,Leonardo Pagani,Malika Abderrahmane,Juliette Camuset,Catherine Legall,Pascale Longuet-Flandres,Anne-Marie Menn,Gwenolée Prevost,Marie Lecronier,Charles Burdet,Ouda Derradji,Lelia Escaut,Etienne Hinglais,Philippe Lebras,Edouard Lefevre,Mathilde Noaillon,Pauline Rabier,Maurice Raphaël,Elina Teicher,Christiane Verny,Daniel Vittecoq,Benjamin Wyplosz,Michèle Ben Hayoun,Françoise Brun-Vezinet,Enrique Casalino,Christophe Choquet,Xavier Duval,Nadhira Houhou,Véronique Joly,Xavier Lescure,Manuela Pogliaghi,Christophe Rioux,Yazdan Yazdanpanah,Elsa Barros,Belinda Begga,Sébastien Boukobza,Houria Bouredji,Imad Chouahi,Isabelle Delacroix,Antoine Froissart,Valérie Garrait,Elsa Ngwem,Catherine Phlippoteau,Sepehr Salehabadi,Cécile Toper,Florent Vinas,Marie Amsilli,Olivier Epaulard,Patricia Pavese,Isabelle Pierre,Jean-Paul Stahl,Jérôme Aulagnier,Julie Celerier,Roxana Cojocariu,Charlotte Rachline,Yoland Schoindre,Thomas Sene,Christelle Thierry,Caroline Aparicio,Amanda Lopes,Marjolaine Morgand Pierre,Sellier,Guy Simoneau,Catherine Chakvetadze,Arnaud Gauthier,Kaoutar Jidar,Béatrice Jourdain,Jean-Francois Boitiaux,Patrick Deschamps,Edouard Devaud,Bruno Philippe,Ruxandra-Oana Calin,Tomasz Chroboczek,Benjamin Davido,Pierre de Truchis,Claire Chapuzet,Laure Chauffrey,Manuel Etienne,Luc-Marie Joly,Bérengère Obstoy,Mathieu Salaun,Luc Thiberville,Julie Tillon,Diane Bollens,Julie Bottero,Pauline Campa,Gäelle Cosqueric,Bénédicte Lefebvre,Zineb Ouazene,Jérôme Pacanowski,Dominique Pateron,Nadia Valin,Caroline Compain,Hugues Cordel,Benoit Doumenc,Elena Fois,Nicolas Gambier,Marie-Aude Khuong,Elisa Pasqualoni,Marie Poupard
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cmi.2024.05.003
Abstract:Objectives: In this study, we aimed to assess the efficacy of different ways of administration and types of beta-lactams for hospitalized community-acquired pneumonia (CAP). Methods: In this post-hoc analysis of randomized controlled trials (RCT) on patients hospitalized for CAP (pneumonia short treatment trial) comparing 3-day vs. 8-day durations of beta-lactams, which concluded to non-inferiority, we included patients who received either amoxicillin-clavulanate (AMC) or third-generation cephalosporin (3GC) regimens, and exclusively either intravenous or oral treatment for the first 3 days (followed by either 5 days of oral placebo or AMC according to randomization). The choice of route and molecule was left to the physician in charge. The main outcome was a failure at 15 days after the first antibiotic intake, defined as temperature >37.9°C, and/or absence of resolution/improvement of respiratory symptoms, and/or additional antibiotic treatment for any cause. The primary outcome according to the route of administration was evaluated through logistic regression. Inverse probability treatment weighting with a propensity score model was used to adjust for non-randomization of treatment routes and potential confounders. The difference in failure rates was also evaluated among several sub-populations (AMC vs. 3GC treatments, intravenous vs. oral AMC, patients with multi-lobar infection, patients aged ≥65 years old, and patients with CURB65 scores of 3-4). Results: We included 200 patients from the original trial, with 93/200 (46.5%) patients only treated with intravenous treatment and 107/200 (53.5%) patients only treated with oral therapy. The failure rate at Day 15 was not significantly different among patients treated with initial intravenous vs. oral treatment [25/93 (26.9%) vs. 28/107 (26.2%), adjusted odds ratios (aOR) 0.973 (95% CI 0.519-1.823), p 0.932)]. Failure rates at Day 15 were not significantly different among the subgroup populations. Discussion: Among hospitalized patients with CAP, there was no significant difference in efficacy between initial intravenous and exclusive oral treatment. Trial registration: This trial is registered with ClinicalTrials.gov, NCT01963442.