Multi-scale gyrokinetic simulations of JT-60U L-mode plasma: reduction of the ionscale energy loss due to the nonlinear coupling with the electron scale turbulence

Shaokang Xu,Shinya Maeyama,Tomo-Hiko Watanabe

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1741-4326/ad1f0c

IF: 3.3

2024-01-18

Nuclear Fusion

Abstract:We investigate the effect of the electron temperature gradient (ETG) driven turbulence on the energy transport in JT-60U L-mode plasma by means of the multi-scale gyrokinetic simulation. In the core region at r/a = 0.5, the instability in the ion scale is driven by the ion temperature gradient (ITG), meanwhile strong unstable ETG modes are found in the electron scale. The nonlinear multi-scale gyrokinetic simulation shows that ETG modes are stabilized in the nonlinear phase and the energy transport in the multi-scale simulation is similar to that obtained in the ion scale ITG simulation. In an outer region at r/a = 0.6, the ion scale instability changes to be the trapped electron mode (TEM). The multi-scale simulation shows that both the ion and the electron energy flux are reduced by ∼ 30% compared to those obtained in the single scale TEM simulation. Interestingly, the electron energy flux is close to the experimental value after this reduction. From the data analyses, we find that ETG turbulence damps the energy of TEM modes through the ion scale/electron scale coupling and the electron scale/electron scale coupling, and can be modeled as a turbulent diffusion of TEM modes. These results suggest that the single ion scale simulation seems to be still valid in the inner region with r/a ≲ 0.5. However, in the outer region it is necessary to include the ETG modes in the gyrokinetic simulations to explain the energy transport in this L-mode plasma. This is the first result showing that ETG turbulence can reduce the electron energy loss via the cross-scale interaction in a real tokamak equilibrium profile.

physics, fluids & plasmas

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the influence of electron - temperature - gradient (ETG) - driven turbulence on energy transfer at different scales in JT - 60U L - mode plasmas. Specifically:

1. **Core region (r/a = 0.5)**:
- In this region, ion - scale instabilities are mainly driven by ion - temperature - gradient (ITG), and at the same time, there are strong ETG unstable modes on the electron scale.
- Research shows that in the nonlinear stage, the ETG mode is stabilized, resulting in energy transfer in multi - scale simulations being similar to the results of ITG simulations considering only the ion scale. This indicates that in the core region, single - ion - scale simulations are still valid.

2. **Outer - edge region (r/a = 0.6)**:
- In this region, ion - scale instabilities transform into trapped - electron modes (TEM), and the ETG mode is also very unstable on the electron scale.
- Multi - scale simulations show that when the ETG mode is included, the ion and electron energy fluxes are reduced by about 30% compared to single - scale simulations considering only the TEM mode. In particular, the electron energy flux is close to the experimental measurement value.

Through these studies, the paper reveals that ETG turbulence can reduce electron energy loss through cross - scale interactions, and when explaining energy transfer in L - mode plasmas, the influence of the ETG mode must be considered in multi - scale gyrokinetic simulations of magnetically - confined fusion plasmas. This is the first result showing that ETG turbulence reduces electron energy loss through cross - scale interactions in a real tokamak equilibrium profile.