Compliance with the 24-hour movement behavior guidelines and the impact of sleep methods amongst toddler, preschool, and school-aged children enrolled in the Guelph family health study

Hannah J. Coyle-Asbil,Becky Breau,David W.L. Ma,Jess Haines,Andrea C. Buchholz,Lori Ann Vallis
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsams.2024.05.014
IF: 4.597
2024-05-31
Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport
Abstract:Canadian movement guidelines focused on physical activity (PA), sleep, and screen time support childhood development and reduce the risk of chronic disease. Accelerometers are often used to capture these behaviors; however, they are limited in their ability to record daytime sleep due to potential misclassification. Objectives The objectives of this study were to 1) determine the prevalence of children enrolled in the Guelph Family Health Study who met the guidelines and to 2) compare the impact of different sleep measurement methods. Design/Methods Toddlers (1.5 to < 3 years; n = 128; valid data for all movement behaviors, n = 70), preschoolers (3 to < 5 years; n = 143; valid data for all movement behaviors, n = 104), and school-aged (5 to < 6 years; n = 49; valid data for all movement behaviors, n = 31) children were included. Screen time and sleep habits were obtained through parental report and published normative data. PA and sleep were recorded using accelerometers (wGT3X-BT ActiGraph; right hip). Results It was found that 66 % of toddler, 44 % of preschool, and 63 % of school-aged children met the screen time guidelines. Further, 63 % of toddler, 98 % of preschooler, and 80 % of school-aged children met PA guidelines. Sleep guideline compliance ranged from 3 %–83 % in toddler, 27 %–92 % in preschooler, and 32 %–90 % in school-aged children. These proportions were found to be significantly different (Cochran's Q and McNemar's tests). Conclusions Nearly all children met PA guidelines. In contrast, less than half to two-thirds met screen time guidelines. Compliance with sleep guidelines varied substantially with measurement method, highlighting the need for standardization.
sport sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?