Abstract:Temperature is one of the major environmental factors that people are exposed to on a daily basis, often in conditions that do not afford control. It is known that heat and cold can influence a person’s productivity and performance in simple tasks. With respect to social cognition, it has also been suggested that temperature impacts on relatively high-level forms of decision-making. For instance, previous research demonstrated that cold temperature promotes utilitarian judgment in a moral dilemma task. This effect could be due to psychological processing, when a cool temperature primes a set of internal representations (associated with “coldness”). Alternatively, the promotion of utilitarian judgment in cold conditions could be due to physiological interference from temperature, impeding on social cognition. Refuting both explanations of psychological or physiological processing, however, it has been suggested that there may be problems of reproducibility in the literature on temperature modulating complex or abstract information processing. To examine the role of temperature in moral decision-making, we conducted a series of experiments using ambient and haptic temperature with careful manipulation checks and modified task methodology. Experiment 1 manipulated room temperature with cool (21°C), control (24°C) and hot (27°C) conditions and found only a cool temperature effect, promoting utilitarian judgment as in the previous study. Experiment 2 manipulated the intensity of haptic temperature but failed to obtain the cool temperature effect. Experiments 3 and 4 examined the generalizability of the cool ambient temperature effect with another moral judgment task and with manipulation of exposure duration. However, again there were no cool temperature effects, suggesting a lack of reproducibility. Despite successful manipulations of temperature in all four experiments, as measured in body temperature and the participants’ self-reported perception, we found no systematic influence of temperature on moral decision-making. A Bayesian meta-analysis of the four experiments showed that the overall data tended to provide strong support in favor of the null hypothesis. We propose that, at least in the range of temperatures from 21 to 27°C, the cool temperature effect in moral decision-making is not a robust phenomenon.

Split personalities? Behavioral effects of temperature on financial decision‐making

Heat and Economic Preferences

What is the relationship between risk attitudes and ambient temperature? Evidence from a large population-based cohort study

The temperature effect on perceived income

A multinational analysis of how emotions relate to economic decisions regarding time or risk

How Do Personality Traits of Young Adults Affect Their Attitudes to Risk and Investment Decisions?

Influences of Indoor Air Temperatures on Empathy and Positive Affect

Beyond the Big Five: How Dynamic Personality Traits Predict Financial Risk Tolerance?

Strike while the iron is hot: Temperature affects consumers' appetite for risk

The effects of temperature on prosocial and antisocial behaviour: A review and meta-analysis

Temperature and Mental Health: Evidence from Helpline Calls

Regional ambient temperature is associated with human personality

Financial Decision Making and Individual Dispositions

The Role of Temperature in Moral Decision-Making: Limited Reproducibility

The stability of personality traits in adolescence and young adulthood

Variable and dynamic associations between hot weather, thermal comfort, and individuals' emotional states during summertime

Disentangling the within- and between-person effects of personality on income for men and women

Warmer or cooler: the influence of ambient temperature on complex choices

The Effect of Income and Wealth on Behavioral Strategies, Personality Traits, and Preferences

Stability of Cloninger's temperament traits following a health event: Subjective and objective health status analysis from the Northern Finland Birth Cohort 1966

Preferences for climate change-related fiscal policies in European countries: drivers and seasonal effects