Tracing the dynamics of superconducting order via transient terahertz third-harmonic generation

Min-Jae Kim,Sergey Kovalev,Mattia Udina,Rafael Haenel,Gideok Kim,Matteo Puviani,Georg Cristiani,Igor Ilyakov,Thales V A G de Oliveira,Alexey Ponomaryov,Jan-Christoph Deinert,Gennady Logvenov,Bernhard Keimer,Dirk Manske,Lara Benfatto,Stefan Kaiser,Thales V. A. G. de Oliveira

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.adi7598

IF: 13.6

2024-03-17

Science Advances

Abstract:Ultrafast optical control of quantum systems is an emerging field of physics. In particular, the possibility of light-driven superconductivity has attracted much of attention. To identify nonequilibrium superconductivity, it is necessary to measure fingerprints of superconductivity on ultrafast timescales. Recently, nonlinear THz third-harmonic generation (THG) was shown to directly probe the collective degrees of freedoms of the superconducting condensate, including the Higgs mode. Here, we extend this idea to light-driven nonequilibrium states in superconducting La 2- x Sr x CuO 4 , establishing an optical pump–THz–THG drive protocol to access the transient superconducting order-parameter quench and recovering on few-picosecond timescales. We show in particular the ability of two-dimensional TH spectroscopy to disentangle the effects of optically excited quasiparticles from the pure order-parameter dynamics, which are unavoidably mixed in the pump-driven linear THz response. Benchmarking the gap dynamics to existing experiments shows the ability of driven THG spectroscopy to overcome these limitations in ordinary pump-probe protocols.

multidisciplinary sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to solve the problem of how to track the dynamics of photo - induced non - equilibrium states in the superconducting state through the transient terahertz third - harmonic generation (THG) technique. Specifically, the research team focuses on how to use the optical - pumping - terahertz - driving protocol to detect the transient change of the superconducting order parameter and its recovery process in the superconducting material La2 - xSrxCuO4.

### Background and Objectives of the Paper

Ultrafast optical control in superconductors is an emerging research field, and in particular, light - driven superconducting phenomena have attracted a great deal of attention. In order to identify superconductivity in non - equilibrium states, it is necessary to measure the characteristic signals of superconductivity on an ultrafast time scale. In recent years, nonlinear terahertz third - harmonic generation (THG) has been proven to be able to directly detect the collective degrees of freedom of the superconducting condensate, including the Higgs mode. This paper further extends on this basis and studies the transient quenching and recovery processes of the superconducting order parameter in superconducting La2 - xSrxCuO4 through the optical - pumping - terahertz - THG driving protocol.

### Main Problems

1. **Transient Dynamics of the Superconducting Order Parameter**:
- How to accurately measure the change of the superconducting order parameter on an ultrafast time scale?
- How to distinguish between the photo - excited quasiparticle effect and pure order - parameter dynamics?

2. **Application of Nonlinear THG Technique**:
- How to use the nonlinear THG technique to detect the dynamic changes of the superconducting condensate?
- How to separate the effects of different dynamic processes through 2D spectroscopy technique?

### Solutions

1. **Experimental Methods**:
- Use an optical - pumping pulse to excite the superconductor, and then use a multi - cycle terahertz driving field to detect the nonlinear response of the superconducting condensate.
- By adjusting the pump - drive delay time and the gated acquisition time, achieve accurate measurement of the transient change of the superconducting order parameter.

2. **Data Processing**:
- Use 2D spectroscopy technique to separate the photo - excited quasiparticle effect and pure order - parameter dynamics.
- By normalizing the TH signal with the fundamental frequency (FH) signal, extract the contribution of the nonlinear optical kernel, thereby directly detecting the dynamics of the superconducting order parameter.

### Results and Discussion

- **Transient Dynamics**:
- The experimental results show that the superconducting order parameter is rapidly quenched (within about 1 picosecond) after photo - excitation and recovers to the equilibrium state within about 9 picoseconds.
- These time scales are consistent with the results of other copper - based superconductors measured by time - resolved angle - resolved photo - electron spectroscopy (TR - ARPES).

- **Modulation of Nonlinear THG Signals**:
- The observed modulation signals at 2Ω and 4Ω frequencies can be explained by four - wave mixing processes, which lead to additional sideband signals.
- Through 2D spectroscopy technique, these sideband signals can be effectively separated, thus enabling a clearer observation of the transient change of the superconducting order parameter.

- **Temperature and Excitation Density Dependence**:
- The changes of THG signals at different temperatures and excitation densities were studied, and it was found that the THG signal increases at low excitation density and is suppressed at high excitation density, which is related to the quenching of the superconducting order parameter.

### Conclusion

Through the optical - pumping - terahertz driving protocol and 2D spectroscopy technique, the research team has successfully separated the photo - excited quasiparticle effect and the transient dynamics of the superconducting order parameter. This method provides new tools and technical means for in - depth understanding of the non - equilibrium state dynamics in superconducting materials.