Abstract:The emphasis of risk has been recognized as a crucial component to effective and successful policy compliance amidst a crisis. Yet, during the COVID-19 pandemic, when the impact of risk may fluctuate with the severity of the prolonged pandemic, and that the public consider not only public health factors when they choose but also whether to follow a COVID-19-related policy, perceived risk may not always lead to policy compliance. Two cross-sectional online surveys (during almost zero case period in late April to May, 2020 (Wave 2) and during the biggest outbreak in July, 2020 (Wave 3)) with convenient sampling were conducted to examine the dichotomous role of perceived severity and perceived susceptibility in influencing policy compliance in Hong Kong. A total of 1816 responses from local adults were collected (Wave 2: N = 564; Female % = 69.7%; Mean age = 39.4; Wave 3: N = 1252; Female %=68.8%; Mean age = 40.2). Although policy compliance is found to increase with the scale of the outbreak, results from path analyses showed that perceived susceptibility and perceived severity have an indirect role in policy complying behaviour when the objective risk is low. Risk variables, including attitude, knowledge, benefit and trust, have directly shaped policy compliance. More importantly, perceived severity boosts policy compliance but perceived susceptibility was associated with disobedience to public health policies. Meanwhile, Hong Kong citizens have a selective and conscious preference regarding the stringency of public health policy: They welcome more law and order, with increasing magnitude of penalty, but reject lockdown measures such as a curfew. Regression results implied that demography had a mild contribution to the acceptance of public health policies, with only the female gender being statistically related to higher policy acceptance. The findings of this study imply that boosting attitude, knowledge, benefit and trust would come more directly helpful in promoting public health policy compliance than emphasizing on risks alone. This study calls for further reflection on the traditional role of risk, especially perceived susceptibility, in mobilizing policy compliance to COVID-19-related measures.

Private efforts, public test policy and insurance against pandemic health risks

How could a pooled testing policy have performed in managing the early stages of the COVID‐19 pandemic? Results from a simulation study

Response toward Public Health Policy Ambiguity and Insurance Decisions

Indemnifying precaution: economic insights for regulation of a highly infectious disease

The Testing Multiplier: Fear vs Containment

Welfare-Maximizing Pooled Testing

Pandemic and insurance purchase: How do people respond to unprecedented risk and uncertainty?

On the efficiency of insurance institutions under interdependent risks

Modelling the Utility of Group Testing for Public Health Surveillance

The impact of public health education on people's demand for commercial health insurance: Empirical evidence from China

Can major public health emergencies increase the participation of commercial insurance? Evidence from China

The Impacts of Testing Susceptible and Exposed Individuals on Emerging Infectious Diseases with Infectiousness in Incubation Period

Rational social distancing policy during epidemics with limited healthcare capacity

Pandemics, public policy, and Peltzman effects

Betting against pandemics: Ethical implications of the "COVID Claimania" in Taiwan, 2020-2022

Testing and Isolation Efficacy: Insights from a Simple Epidemic Model

Policy evaluation during a pandemic

The optimisation of public health emergency governance: a simulation study based on COVID-19 pandemic control policy

Health Insurance and Health Status: Exploring the Causal Effect from A Policy Intervention

The Impact of a Public Health Emergency on the Demand for Life Insurance – An Empirical Analysis Based on Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome

Risk perception as a double-edged sword in policy compliance in COVID-19 pandemic? A two-phase evaluation from Hong Kong