Exchanging Housing Dollars for Health Care Savings: The Impact of Housing First on Health Care Costs
Kevin Brennan,Singumbe Muyeba,Kathryn Buggs,Alexis Henry,John Gettens,Parag Kunte,Kevin BrennanSingumbe MuyebaKathryn BuggsAlexis HenryJohn GettensParag Kuntea College of Business,University of Akron,Akron,OH,USAb Josef Korbel School of International Studies,University of Denver,Denver,CO,USAc Family Medicine and Community Health,University of Massachusetts Medical School,Worcester,MA,USAd Commonwealth Medicine,University of Massachusetts Medical School,Shrewsbury,MA,USAKevin Brennan is Assistant Professor at the University of Akron. He has served as Assistant Dean for Information Technologies for the Simon School of business at the University of Rochester,Rochester NY. He has also led engagements to provide expert technical advice and analytical services to clients of Analysis Group,Inc.,a multinational consulting firm specializing in economic strategy and analysis for complex business litigation. Analysis Group provided analytical services pro bono on this project.Singumbe Muyeba is Assistant Professor at the University of Denver's Josef Korbel School of International Studies. His research focuses on the effects of housing,homeownership and homelessness in developing and developed countries.Kathryn Buggs just completed her law degree at the University of Chicago. Previously,she was a Senior Analyst at Analysis Group,Inc. until July 2020 and worked on the analytical team for this project.Alexis Henry is Associate Professor of Psychiatry at ForHealth Consulting at UMass Chan Medical School.John (Jack) Gettens,PhD,is Assistant Professor of Family Medicine and Community Health Research and Evaluation Unit within the Public and Private Health Solutions arm at Commonwealth Medicine at the University of Massachusetts Medical School.Parag Kunte is Senior Biostatistician for the Research and Evaluation Unit within the Public and Private Health Solutions arm at Commonwealth Medicine at the University of Massachusetts Medical School
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10511482.2023.2297976
2024-01-08
Housing Policy Debate
Abstract:This paper assesses the effects of the Housing First model on the utilization of public health services and claims among chronically homeless individuals and in the process addresses the problem of attribution to natural stabilization on account of regression to the mean. The study uses Medicaid claims data from participants in a Massachusetts "Housing First" program (n = 1,342) and non-participants (n = 44,022) who included chronically homeless individuals. A control group design, propensity score matching techniques, and difference in differences were employed to estimate effects on utilization of and claims for emergency room visits, inpatient hospitalization, mental health encounters, and pharmacy and other claims. We find that both groups registered statistically significant pre–post improvements in utilization of health care services and claims, but these are greater among the Housing First cohort. The findings suggest that Housing First significantly reduces utilization of health care services beyond regression to the mean and that the resultant health care savings offset a significant portion of the cost of housing. Policy proponents and opponents of Housing First must recognize that the model has a significant portion of its costs offset by savings from lower Medicaid claims.
urban studies,development studies