Islands of diversity

Marian Turner

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41559-023-02286-4

IF: 19.1

2024-01-11

Nature Ecology & Evolution

Abstract:Oil palm trees were introduced to Southeast Asia around a century ago; now, plantations cover millions of hectares of land and the region supplies most of the global demand for palm oil. This crop growth has brought economic development (including to many smallholder farmers), but the conversion of biodiverse forest to oil palm plantations has reduced ecosystem functioning in the region. Writing in Nature in May 2023, Zemp et al. suggest a restoration strategy that enables enhanced biodiversity without reduced oil palm productivity. The authors report on a five-year experiment in which 52 'islands' of native trees, of varying size and with between zero (natural regeneration) and six tree species, were planted across a 140-hectare oil-palm plantation in Indonesia that was otherwise essentially a monoculture. Three to five years after the tree islands were planted, the researchers used methods that ranged from acoustic monitoring of birds to laser scanning of vegetation structure to evaluate 10 indicators of aboveground and belowground biodiversity and 19 indicators of ecosystem functioning. This broad assessment enabled the authors to show not only that biodiversity and ecosystem multifunctionality were higher in tree islands, but also that larger tree islands led to larger gains — primarily because those islands became dominated by trees other than oil palms. Although oil palm yield was on average 24% lower than in the surrounding monocultures, the thinning of palm trees that was conducted to plant the native trees actually led to gains in yield around the islands, which compensated for the reductions within the islands. The authors suggest that, even with longer periods of tree island establishment, there would not be substantial yield losses when considered at the scale of an industrial oil-palm plantation. We highlight this paper because it exemplifies a feasible and potentially economically palatable strategy to restore some ecosystem function in these heavily impacted landscapes.

ecology,evolutionary biology