Grit as a predictor of academic performance: Not much more than conscientiousness

Tyler L. Minnigh,Jennifer M. Sanders,Stephanie M. Witherell,Thomas R. Coyle
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.paid.2024.112542
IF: 3.95
2024-01-27
Personality and Individual Differences
Abstract:This research examined whether grit or its facets would predict college GPAs after removing variance shared with conscientiousness. Official SAT total scores and GPAs were obtained from 401 university students. Grit was measured with the Short Grit Scale, and conscientiousness was measured with a 24-item International Personality Item Pool-based measure of conscientiousness. Structural equation modeling was used to examine relationships between grit, conscientiousness, SAT scores, and GPAs. The unique variances of grit and its facets were used to predict GPAs. Neither grit nor its facets predicted college GPAs after removing variance shared with conscientiousness and controlling for SAT scores. Grit and the perseverance of effort facet of grit were also found to be negatively related to SAT scores. These results suggest that grit and its facets are not sufficiently distinct from conscientiousness to incrementally predict academic performance, nor do grit or its facets compensate for differences in cognitive ability when used to predict academic performance. Future research is needed to examine whether measures of grit can be improved or if goal-specific grit measures may be more useful for predicting important outcomes.
psychology, social
What problem does this paper attempt to address?