Abstract:The productivity of Pacific Sockeye salmon ( Oncorhynchus nerka ) in the Columbia River has been declining over the past century. Yet, the Okanagan River Sockeye salmon population, which spawns in the Okanagan River, a Canadian tributary of the Columbia River, has seen a remarkable turnaround in abundance. Different hypotheses and lines of evidence covering multiple spatial scales have been proposed to explain this recovery; but they have never been comprehensively assessed. We adopted a weight-of-evidence approach to systematically assess the relative likelihood that each of these causal hypotheses contributed to the observed recovery. Our analysis disentangles the relative consequences of a set of environmental management actions that have been implemented to augment the Sockeye salmon freshwater productivity, while accounting for changes in freshwater and marine environmental conditions. Our list of potentially explanatory causal factors (anthropogenic and natural) included: (1) changes in escapement concurrent with improving local fish passage, (2) the implementation of fish-friendly flows in the Okanagan River, (3) initiating a hatchery restocking program, (4) potential improvements to Columbia dam operations to support higher relative survival of out-migrating juvenile fish, (5) possible shifts in survival-favorable conditions in the coastal marine environment for ocean-going life stages, and (6) broader changes to multi-stock harvest regimes in the Columbia River. Our assessment leveraged comparisons with the population dynamics of another Sockeye salmon stock in the Columbia River basin to differentiate between the impacts of management actions taken within the Okanagan watershed (our focus) from those occurring over the broader basin and marine scale. The results suggest that while shifts towards survival-favorable conditions in the coastal marine environment in 2007 played an important role in the upturn of the Okanagan population, alone it cannot explain the rate at which the Okanagan River Sockeye salmon recovered. Strong evidence supports the combined effect of increased escapement in conjunction with establishing and securing fish-friendly flows during spawning, incubation, and alevin emergence. Additionally, Sockeye salmon restocking improved the resilience of the stock against density-independent mortality events. These combined basin-level management actions played a pivotal role in magnifying the recovery trajectory afforded by improved marine survivorship. The spectacular response of the Okanagan River Sockeye salmon to the holistic perspectives and management interventions of Indigenous and other caretakers provides hope that other Pacific salmon stocks can be stabilized and recovered.

Fishing in turbulent waters: resilience, risk, and trust in British Columbia's declining commercial salmon fishery

Learning from Indigenous knowledge holders on the state and future of wild Pacific salmon

Social climate resilience: Evidence from a traditional surf clam fishery community in Chile

One hundred‐seventy years of stressors erode salmon fishery climate resilience in California’s warming landscape

Monitoring for fisheries or for fish? Declines in monitoring of salmon spawners continue despite a conservation crisis

Attributes of climate resilience in fisheries: From theory to practice

Developing U.S. West Coast recreational fishing community measures: Applying an index approach in the context of COVID-19 and social vulnerability

Exploring spatio-temporal changes in coastal recreational fisheries and potential links to extreme weather events

Accounting for salmon body size declines in fishery management can reduce conservation risks

Perspectives on managing fisheries for community wellbeing in the face of climate change

A Weight-of-Evidence Approach for Understanding the Recovery of Okanagan Sockeye Salmon

Fish catch responses to Covid-19 disease curfews dependent on compliance, fisheries management, and environmental contexts

The complex interaction of ecology and hydrology in a small catchment: a salmon's perspective

Fishermen using social-ecological resilience adapting coastal disasters

Analyzing fisher effort -- Gender differences and the impact of Covid-19

Social-ecological vulnerability to environmental extremes and adaptation pathways in small-scale fisheries of the southern California Current

Environmental conditions on the Pacific halibut fishing grounds obtained from a decade of coastwide oceanographic monitoring, and the potential application of these data in stock analyses

Restoring freshwater habitat mosaics to promote resilience of vulnerable salmon populations

Biodiversity underpins fisheries resilience to exploitation in the Amazon river basin

Fish resilience as an ethical issue

Trade-offs in fishing strategy decisions and conservation implications for small-scale fisheries