Maturity Model for Sustainability Assessment of Chemical Analyses Laboratories in Public Higher Education Institutions

Marco Antonio Souza,Mario Orestes Aguirre González,André Luís Santos de Pinho
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16052137
IF: 3.9
2024-03-06
Sustainability
Abstract:The increasing demand for sustainable products and services has become a constant requirement for the different stakeholders in an organization. Higher Education Institutions (HEI) have a crucial role in training conscious and competent professionals to lead these changes. Chemical analyses laboratories bring together the proper mix, where the adoption of mature and efficient management systems proves to be crucial not only to better train the institutions' human resources but also to cooperate in recruiting research projects and other services to benefit society. Maturity models assist in the needed stages for sustainable growth to take place. This paper proposes a maturity model based on standardized norms to guide adjustments related to quality, risks, safety, and environment of chemical analyses laboratories in public higher education institutions. This research was done in four stages: theoretical research about maturity models, sustainability, and integrated management systems; survey with laboratories; case study at a chemical analyses laboratory of an HEI; and structuring and validating a maturity model. As the main results, it was observed that more than 80% of public laboratory managers believe it would be relevant to adopt a maturity model to help organize the laboratory's internal and external processes. 86% of public laboratory managers understand that using management systems can contribute to hiring new services. We can also observe that 42.9% of public laboratory managers do not know any maturity model. As conclusion, the model includes eight dimensions, 31 subdimensions, and 204 management practices to assess and guide chemical analyses laboratories to sustainable maturity levels.
environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve are: how to use the maturity model to help chemical analysis laboratories reach a higher level of sustainable development, and how to promote the development of sustainable policies and actions in higher education institutions (HEIs) through this model. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects: 1. **Integration and Standardization of Management Systems**: It investigates whether the maturity model based on a standardized management system is relevant to laboratory managers and how such a model can positively impact sustainability at the laboratory level. 2. **Willingness to Adopt Management Systems**: Whether managers of chemical analysis laboratories are interested in adopting a standardized management system to organize and improve their processes. 3. **Status of Existing Management Systems**: Whether chemical analysis laboratories in universities and higher education institutions already have structured management systems or only isolated tools and/or methods to coordinate and control their operations and daily affairs. 4. **Feasibility of the Maturity Model**: Whether a maturity model suitable for the chemical analysis laboratory environment can be constructed to achieve sustainable activities. The paper explores these issues through the following hypotheses: - P1: The maturity model based on a standardized management system is relevant to managers and positively impacts sustainability at the laboratory level. - P2: Managers of chemical analysis laboratories in higher education institutions are interested in adopting a standardized management system to organize and improve their processes. - P3: Chemical analysis laboratories in universities and higher education institutions do not have structured management systems but use isolated tools and/or methods to coordinate and control their operations and daily affairs. - P4: A maturity model suitable for the chemical analysis laboratory environment can be constructed to gradually achieve sustainable activities. Through these hypotheses, the paper aims to provide a systematic method for chemical analysis laboratories to help them gradually improve their management levels in terms of quality, risk, safety, and environment, thereby achieving sustainable development.