The Gender Implications of Public Sector Downsizing : The Reform Program of Vietnam

Martín Rama
Abstract:Men and women may be affected differently by major economic reforms and, especially, by public sector downsizing. Unfortunately the literature is not informative enough to predict the effects of a specific program. This article illustrates several analyses that could precede the launching of a sizeable downsizing operation, taking Vietnam as an example. First, the article uses employment data to assess the prospects for women to get salaried jobs. While these prospects worsened with recent reforms, they are bound to improve in the near future. Second, it estimates Mincerian equations to predict how reforms could affect the gender gap in labor earnings. Reforms are associated with a sharp decline in the gender gap, both in the state sector and out of it. Third, it analyzes the correlation between female employment and indicators of labor redundancy by sector. Over-staffing is concentrated in male-dominated activities, such as construction, mining and transportation, but is smaller in female-dominated activities, such as footwear, textile and garments. Fourth, the article reviews programs that are in place to assist redundant workers, such as early retirement and re-training. It uncovers no evidence of a strong gender bias in them. Finally, the article assesses the potential gender biases of three standard compensation packages for redundant workers. Packages defined as a multiple of earnings would be more favorable to men, whereas lump-sum packages would favor women. * This paper was written for the second phase of the research project on Efficient Public Sector Downsizing (RPO 683-67), with support from the Vietnam Country Office, East Asia and Pacific Region. The author is grateful to Sarah Bales, Robert Baulch, Alberto Chong, Andrew Mason, Phan Thi Thanh and Tosca Van Vijfeijken for comments, suggestions and help with the data, and to Ta Phuong Dzung for assistance with translations. The findings and interpretations in the paper should not be attributed to the World Bank.
Economics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?