Comparative efficacy of THR-β agonists, FGF-21 analogues, GLP-1R agonists, GLP-1-based polyagonists, and Pan-PPAR agonists for MASLD: A systematic review and network meta-analysis
Ru-Tao Lin,Qin-Mei Sun,Xin Xin,Cheng Han Ng,Luca Valenti,Yi-Yang Hu,Ming-Hua Zheng,Qin Feng
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.metabol.2024.156043
IF: 13.934
2024-09-30
Metabolism
Abstract:Aims: To compare the efficacy of thyroid hormone receptor beta (THR-β) agonists, fibroblast growth factor 21 (FGF-21) analogues, glucagon-like peptide-1 receptor agonists (GLP-1RAs), GLP-1-based polyagonists, and pan-peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor (Pan-PPAR) agonists in the treatment of metabolic dysfunction-associated steatotic liver disease (MASLD). Methods: A database search for relevant randomized double-blind controlled trials published until July 11, 2024, was conducted. Primary outcomes were the relative change in hepatic fat fraction (HFF) and liver stiffness assessed non-invasively by magnetic resonance imaging proton density fat fraction and elastography. Secondary outcomes included histology, liver injury index, lipid profile, glucose metabolism, blood pressure, and body weight. Results: Twenty-seven trials (5357 patients with MASLD) were identified. For HFF reduction, GLP-1-based polyagonists were most potentially effective (mean difference [MD] -51.47; 95 % confidence interval [CI]: -68.25 to -34.68; surface under the cumulative ranking curve [SUCRA] 84.9) vs. placebo, followed by FGF-21 analogues (MD -47.08; 95 % CI: -58.83 to -35.34; SUCRA 75.5), GLP-1R agonists (MD -37.36; 95 % CI: -69.52 to -5.21; SUCRA 52.3) and THR-β agonists (MD -33.20; 95 % CI: -43.90 to -22.51; SUCRA 36.9). For liver stiffness, FGF-21 analogues were most potentially effective (MD -9.65; 95 % CI: -19.28 to -0.01; SUCRA 82.2) vs. placebo, followed by THR-β agonists (MD -5.79; 95 % CI: -9.50 to -2.09; SUCRA 58.2), and GLP-1RAs (MD -5.58; 95 % CI: -15.02 to 3.86; SUCRA 54.7). For fibrosis improvement in histology, GLP-1-based polyagonists were most potentially effective, followed by FGF-21 analogues, THR-β agonists, Pan-PPAR agonists, and GLP-1R agonists; For MASH resolution in histology, GLP-1-based polyagonists were most potentially effective, followed by THR-β agonists, GLP-1R agonists, FGF-21 analogues, and Pan-PPAR agonists. THR-β agonists are well-balanced in liver steatosis and fibrosis, and excel at improving lipid profiles; FGF-21 analogues are effective at improving steatosis and particularly exhibit strong antifibrotic abilities. GLP-1R agonists showed significant benefits in improving liver steatosis, glucose metabolism, and body weight. GLP-1-based polyagonists have demonstrated the most potential efficacy overall in terms of comprehensive curative effect. Pan-PPAR agonists showed distinct advantages in improving liver function and glucose metabolism. Conclusion: These results illustrate the relative superiority of the five classes of therapy in the treatment of MASLD and may serve as guidance for the development of combination therapies.