Mobile Phone Based Interventions for Promoting Adherence to Tuberculosis Treatment: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Shanquan Chen,Yao Pan,Yan Qu,Zhiyong Liu,Lan Yao,Li Xiang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/s0140-6736(15)00867-3
2015-01-01
Abstract:BackgroundPoor adherence to tuberculosis treatment remains a global health challenge, and mobile phone based interventions have the potential to address this problem. This study aimed to systematically review and synthesise existing evidence on the acceptability and efficacy of mobile phone based interventions in improving patients' adherence to tuberculosis treatment.MethodsWe searched Embase, PubMed, WHOLIS, WHOIRIS, Cochrane Library, and Web of Science for studies published in English from Jan 1, 1992, to May 25, 2015, using the search terms "TB", "tuberculosis", "mobile", and "messag*". We also did manual, snowball searches. We included descriptive and qualitative studies of the acceptability of mobile phone based interventions, and randomised controlled trials (RCTs) of efficacy. For descriptive and qualitative studies, a framework analysis was used. For RCTs, we pooled data with a random-effects meta-analysis.Findings70 articles were identified from 6601 initial searches. 14 studies were included (five qualitative studies [270 participants]—two USA, one Peru, one India, one Argentina; six descriptive survey studies [2259]—one South Africa, one India, one Philippines, one China, one Kenya, one USA; three RCTs [566]—one Kenya, one Argentina, one Thailand). 56–82% of patients were willing to accept mobile phone based communication. Developed countries seemed to have lower acceptability than developing ones, but reasonable usage of the mobile phone (for example, frequency of sending SMS) increased the acceptability. Older age and literacy were not crucial limiting factors to participating. The mobile phone based interventions helped overcome barriers such as stigma, loss of privacy, transportation limitations, and burdens associated with traditional interventions, and made participants feel "cared for" and that they were "responsible for their treatment". Compared with participants without mobile phone based interventions, SMS intervention significantly improved adherence to tuberculosis treatment (pooled relative risk 1·155, 95% CI 1·047–1·274), with no evidence of publication bias (Begg test z=0·939, p=0·348) or heterogeneity among trials (χ2=1·039, df=2, p=0·595, I2=0%).InterpretationThese findings support the important role of mobile phone based interventions for promoting adherence to treatment by patients with tuberculosis, which will help policy makers.FundingFunding was received from the Natural Science Foundation of China (no 71203068) and from the China National Health and Family Planning Commission and the Gates Foundation TB Project (no 51914). The funders had no role in the study.