Abstract:Objective The aim of this study was to determine factors related to emergency department (ED) care causing in-patient deterioration. Methods This retrospective cohort study examined in-patient records using the human factors classification framework for patient safety in a regional health service in New South Wales, Australia, between March 2016 and February 2017. Deterioration was defined as either the initiation of a medical emergency team call, cardiac arrest or unplanned admission to the intensive care unit. Results Of the 1074 patients who deteriorated within 72 hours of admission via the ED, the care received in the ED was a contributing factor for 101 patients (9%). The most common human causal factors were poor communication between staff, medical management errors, delayed treatment, medical documentation errors, nursing management errors and unclear policies or guidelines. Communication issues occurred the most when patients had more comorbidities (P = 0.039) and were more likely to occur in the presence of a medical documentation error (odds ratio 4.4; 95% confidence interval 1.7-11.3). Unclear policies or guidelines as a factor was most frequent with a surgical diagnosis (34.5% vs 15.7% for surgical vs medical, respectively; P = 0.038) and in patients ≥80 years of age (30.0% vs 21.8% for age ≥80 vs <80 years, respectively; P = 0.027). Conclusion Quality monitoring and interventions that consider human factors are required to address preventable in-patient deterioration. What is known about the topic? The ED represents the hospital's point of contact for potentially life-threatening conditions. Adverse event rates for emergency admissions are more than double those of non-emergency admissions. Patients are at particular risk of deterioration on discharge from the ED to the ward in the first 72 hours. Predicting which patients will deteriorate following transfer to the ward remains challenging, with care in the ED hypothesised to play a role. What does this paper add? This paper reveals that in-patient deterioration relating to ED care could be reduced through the routine identification of causal factors within a human factors framework in any patient deterioration event and subsequent evidence-informed interventions to address these factors. It is also extrapolated that the implementation of any intervention should be informed by behaviour-change principles. What are the implications for practitioners? It is implied that there is a need for the clarification and revision of policies and guidelines pertaining to the management of elderly patients, education regarding the critical importance of the often clinically masked vital sign deviations in younger patients and improved communication between staff, especially regarding patients with more comorbidities. Reviews of adverse events, such as patient deterioration, should incorporate a human factors analysis. Regular collation of data following adverse events should occur, with interventions considering all aspects of the factors that led to the event.

Prevalence of clinical deterioration in the pre-hospital setting

A prediction model for prehospital clinical deterioration: The use of early warning scores

Ambulance offload performance, patient characteristics and disposition for patients offloaded to different areas of the emergency department

Clinical deterioration in patients with ST-elevation myocardial infarction during and for 24 h after percutaneous coronary intervention: An observational study

Emergency department care-related causal factors of in-patient deterioration

Causes, Diagnostic Testing, and Treatments Related to Clinical Deterioration Events Among High-Risk Ward Patients

Paediatric out-of-hospital clinical deterioration: a mixed-methods scoping review protocol

Detecting Deteriorating Patients in the Hospital: Development and Validation of a Novel Scoring System

Impact of an emergency department rapid response system on inpatient clinical deterioration: A controlled pre-post study

What influences ambulance clinician decisions to pre-alert emergency departments: a qualitative exploration of pre-alert practice in UK ambulance services and emergency departments

Beyond Unplanned ICU Transfers: Linking a Revised Definition of Deterioration to Patient Outcomes

How do emergency departments respond to ambulance pre-alert calls? A qualitative exploration of the management of pre-alerts in UK emergency departments

The deterioration of children in ward areas in a specialist children's hospital

Adverse Events in Patients Transitioning From the Emergency Department to the Inpatient Setting

Listen to me, I really am sick! Patient and family narratives of clinical deterioration before and during rapid response system intervention

Prediction of clinical deterioration risk at 8 hours after arrival in emergency department in non‐traumatic patients using trends in modified early warning score level

Epidemiology and outcome of medical emergency team calls within 48 hours of intensive care unit discharge

Prehospital factors predicting mortality in patients with shock: state-wide linkage study

Improved Sensitivity For Detection Of Clinical Deterioration When Diagnostic Pathology And Patient Trends Are Included In Machine Learning Models

The illness severity of ward remaining patients reviewed by the medical emergency team: A retrospective cohort study

Investigating ward nurses' responses to deteriorating patients