Abstract:Abstract Background Two established small-group learning paradigms in medical education include Case-based learning (CBL) and Team-based learning (TBL). Characteristics common to both pedagogies include the use of an authentic clinical case, active small-group learning, activation of existing knowledge and application of newly acquired knowledge. However, there are also variances between the two teaching methods, and a paucity of studies that consider how these approaches fit with curriculum design principles. In this paper we explore student and facilitator perceptions of the two teaching methods within a medical curriculum, using Experience based learning (ExBL) as a conceptual lens. Methods A total of 34/255 (13%) Year 2 medical students completed four CBLs during the 2019 Renal and Urology teaching block, concurrent to their usual curriculum activities, which included weekly TBLs. Questionnaires were distributed to all students ( n = 34) and CBL facilitators ( n = 13). In addition, all students were invited to attend focus groups. Data were analysed using descriptive statistics and thematic analysis. Results In total, 23/34 (71%) of students and 11/13 (85%) of facilitators completed the questionnaires. Twelve students (35%) participated in focus groups. Findings indicate their experience in CBL to be positive, with many favourable aspects that built on and complemented their TBL experience that provided an emphasis on the basic sciences. The learning environment was enriched by the CBL framework that allowed application of knowledge to solve clinical problems within the small groups with consistent facilitator guidance and feedback, their capacity to focus discussion, and associated efficiencies in learning. Conclusion While the TBL model was integral in developing students’ knowledge and understanding of basic science concepts, the CBL model was integral in developing students’ clinical reasoning skills. The strengths of CBL relative to TBL included the development of authentic clinical reasoning skills and guided facilitation of small group discussion. Our findings suggest that delivery of a medical curriculum may be enhanced through increased vertical integration, applying TBL in earlier phases of the medical program where the focus is on basic science principles, with CBL becoming more relevant as students move towards clinical immersion.

Going P(u)BLIQ: Successfully Transitioning Undergraduate Medical Students from Problem-Based Learning to Inquiry Case Learning Through a Novel Hybrid Approach

Implementation of modified team-based learning within a problem based learning medical curriculum: a focus group study

Interprofessional education in problem-based learning: A frontier form of PBL in medical education

Implementation and Evaluation of a Team-Based Learning Approach Within a Hybrid Problem-Based Learning Medical Education Curriculum

Introducing a problem-based learning program: 12 tips for success

Implementation of problem-based learning modules in an introduction to public health course

Problem-based learning: Student learning experiences and outcomes

Does case-based blended-learning expedite the transfer of declarative knowledge to procedural knowledge in practice?

Implementation of team-based learning in year 1 of a PBL based medical program: a pilot study

Impact of a problem-based learning elective on performance in non-problem-based learning required courses

Decision PBL: A 4-year retrospective case study of the use of virtual patients in problem-based learning

Does blended problem-based learning make Asian medical students active learners?: a prospective comparative study

Team-based learning (TBL) in the medical curriculum: better than PBL?

A comparison of face-to-face and fully online problem-based learning: Student results and staff experiences, 2014-2020

Hybrid PBL and Pure PBL: Which one is more effective in developing clinical reasoning skills for general medicine clerkship?—A mixed-method study

Scaffolding medical student knowledge and skills: team-based learning (TBL) and case-based learning (CBL)

The Benefits of Using Case Study Focussed, Problem Based Learning Approaches to Unit Design for Biomedical Science Students

Using an online quiz-based reinforcement system to teach healthcare quality and patient safety and care transitions at the University of California

Application and evaluation of problem-based learning in undergraduate clinical education in 2014-2018

Development and Evaluation of the POPBL (Patient-Oriented Problem-Based Learning) Module in Pathology: A Comparative Analysis of Performance and Perception Among Second-Year Pathology Students

Viewpoint: leaving the "empty glass" of problem-based learning behind: new assumptions and a revised model for case study in preclinical medical education