Consolidation Carnival: A Case-Based Approach to Reviewing Musculoskeletal Anatomy in an Undergraduate Medical Curriculum
Rosemary Bassey,Robert V Hill,Zeinab Nassrallah,Shannon Knutson,Brian Pinard,Doreen M Olvet,William P Rennie
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/AMEP.S409797
2023-08-12
Advances in Medical Education and Practice
Abstract:Rosemary Bassey, Robert V Hill, Zeinab Nassrallah, Shannon Knutson, Brian Pinard, Doreen M Olvet, William P Rennie Department of Science Education, Donald and Barbara Zucker School of Medicine at Hofstra/ Northwell, Hempstead, NY, USA Correspondence: Rosemary Bassey, Department of Science Education, Donald and Barbara Zucker School of Medicine at Hofstra/ Northwell, Hempstead, NY, 11549, USA, Tel +1 516 463-7504, Email Introduction: Recent changes in undergraduate medical curricula have resulted in time constraints that are particularly challenging, especially when students must learn large blocks of musculoskeletal anatomy content. Consequently, students have resorted to rote memorization to cope, which counteracts our established collaborative self-directed learning model. Methods: For a 6-week musculoskeletal anatomy course, two structured case-based review sessions are described, each following the completion of two five-hour lab sessions, two on the upper extremities and two on the lower extremities. These largely self-directed review sessions consisted of 6 students rotating through 7 to 8 stations every 10 minutes where clinical cases with follow-up questions were projected on large screens. The students were expected to work collaboratively to solve the cases utilizing the prosected specimens provided and discuss the accompanying answers at the end of each case. Results: Ninety-four per cent of the students who participated in this study agreed that the case-based review sessions provided a helpful overview of musculoskeletal anatomy content. Student performance on the open-ended, case-based musculoskeletal examination questions showed no significant difference in performance on shoulder, hand, hip, thigh, and leg questions. There was, however, a statistically significant decrease in the students' scores on a forearm question in 2021 compared to 2019. Conclusion: This paper describes our integrated, collaborative musculoskeletal course, including case-based review sessions, which was positively received by students as having value in reviewing the musculoskeletal content though it was not found to improve examination performance. Keywords: musculoskeletal, anatomy, integrated curriculum, review, consolidation, evaluation Musculoskeletal diseases constitute approximately 20% of all primary care and emergency department visits with trauma, back pain, and arthritis being the three most reported. 1,2 Unfortunately, the burden of musculoskeletal conditions is likely to become greater with every passing year due to the obesity epidemic, upsurge in incidence of road traffic accidents and the fast-growing population of the aged in the United States. 3,4 Furthermore, patients with musculoskeletal disorders are managed by a wide-ranging group of providers including primary care physicians, emergency physicians, surgeons, physical medicine and rehabilitation physicians, anesthesiologists, neurologists, radiologists, rheumatologists, and physical therapists. 5 The mismanagement of musculoskeletal injuries can delay treatment, ultimately resulting in long-term disability. 6–8 Due to the multidisciplinary nature of musculoskeletal disorders, it is important that all physicians-in-training are provided with the requisite knowledge of musculoskeletal anatomy to properly manage patients in the clinical setting. The past decade has seen significant changes in undergraduate medical education, with anatomy teaching at the forefront. 9 Following the introduction of the integrated curriculum in medical schools, anatomy courses have undergone extensive restructuring, including reduction in teaching hours dedicated to formal anatomy education. 10,11 These changes have triggered development of more pedagogies that optimize anatomy content delivery and improve learning outcomes by shifting away from rote memorization, and leaning more towards understanding of content, driven by case-based, problem-solving approaches. 11–14 The implementation of mixed or multimodal learning strategies allows students to acquire knowledge from a variety of sources. This approach has become widely used in the delivery of musculoskeletal anatomy content in many US medical schools. 15–17 Several studies have explored various teaching pedagogies for musculoskeletal anatomy including the use of dissection, prosections, plastic models and 3D anatomy software on students' performance on musculoskeletal examinations. 18–20 Structured exercises like yoga and Pilates to facilitate the learning of musculoskeletal anatomy have also been explored. 21,22 Furthermore, the shift from discipline-based to competency-based curricula has necessitated more vertical integration of -Abstract Truncated-