Abstract:Background: Beam data commissioning is a core task of radiotherapy physicists. Despite multiple detectors available, a feasible measurement program compromises between detector properties and time constraints. Therefore, it is important to understand how nonideal measurement data propagates into patient dose calculation. Purpose: We simulated the effects of realistic errors, due to beam commissioning with presumably nonoptimal detectors, on the resulting patient dose distributions. Additionally, the detectability of such beam commissioning errors during patient plan quality assurance (QA) was evaluated. Methods: A clinically used beam model was re-commissioned introducing changes to depth dose curves, output factors, profiles or combinations of those. Seventeen altered beam models with incremental changes of the modelling parameters were created to analyze dose changes on simplified anatomical phantoms. Additionally, fourteen altered models incorporate changes in the order of signal differences reported for typically used detectors. Eighteen treatment plans of different types were recalculated on patient CT data sets using the altered beam models. Results: For the majority of clinical plans, dose distributions in the target volume recalculated on the patient computed tomography data were similar between the original and the modified beam models, yielding global 2%/2 mm gamma pass rates above 98.9%. Larger changes were observed for certain combinations of beam modelling errors and anatomical sites, most extreme for output factor changes in a small target volume plan with a pass rate of 80.6%. Modelling an enlarged penumbra as if measured with a 0.125 cm3 ion chamber had the largest effect on the dose distribution (average pass rate of 96.5%, lowest 85.4%). On different QA phantom geometries, dose distributions between calculations with modified and unmodified models typically changed too little to be detected in actual measurements. Conclusion: While the simulated errors during beam modelling had little effect on most plans, in some cases changes were considerable. High-quality penumbra and small field output factor should be a main focus of commissioning measurements. Detecting modelling issues using standard patient QA phantoms is unlikely. Verification of a beam model should be performed especially for plans with high modulation and in different depths or geometries representing the variety of situations expected clinically.

Use the external radiotherapy StarTrack detector to study the electron beam profile

Dosimetry evaluation of photon beam profile characteristics for different treatment parameters of quality assurance

A multicenter study of modified electron beam output calibration

A comparative study of photon beam percentage depth dose of a recently installed varian vitalbeam linear accelerator at TMSS cancer center, Bangladesh

An external dosimetry audit programme to credential static and rotational IMRT delivery for clinical trials quality assurance

Small field output factor measurement and verification for CyberKnife robotic radiotherapy and radiosurgery system using 3D polymer gel, ionization chamber, diode, diamond and scintillator detectors, Gafchromic film and Monte Carlo simulation

Dosimetric Systems in Pre-Treatment QA for Stereotactic Treatments: Correlation Agreements and Target Volume Dependency

Simulation of consequences of using nonideal detectors during beam data commissioning measurements

Nanodosimetric investigation of the track structure of therapeutic carbon ion radiation. Part 2: Detailed radiation transport and track structure simulation

Development of a digital star‐shot analysis system for comparing radiation and imaging isocenters of proton treatment machine

Evaluation of patient-specific quality assurance for fractionated stereotactic treatment plans with 6 and 10MV photon beams in beam-matched linacs

Portability of IMRT QA between matched linear accelerators

Computer-Aided Star Shot Analysis for Linac Quality Assurance Testing

Impact of Measurement Conditions and Design Features of IBA Detectors on the Small Radiation Fields Output Factors

Technical Notes: Robustness of three‐dimensional treatment and imaging isocenter testing using a new gel dosimeter and kilovoltage CBCT

Evaluation of RADIANCE Monte Carlo algorithm for treatment planning in electron based Intraoperative Radiotherapy (IOERT)

The influence of beam delivery uncertainty on dose uniformity and penumbra for pencil beam scanning in carbon-ion radiotherapy

Technical and dosimetric aspects of the total skin electron beam technique implemented at Heidelberg University Hospital

The Impact of Dose Calibration Point Differences Between the Treatment Plan and Patient-specific Quality Assurance in Passive Scattering Proton Beam Therapy

Clinical dose assessment for scanned carbon-ion radiotherapy using linear energy transfer measurements and Monte Carlo simulations

A prospective study on the effect of tumor shrinkage on exit fluence gamma pass rate in high precision radiotherapy and influence of phantom setup error in patient-specific quality assurance