Progress in the Technology of Neuromodulation: The Emperor's New Clothes?

R. Levy
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/ner.12103
2013-07-01
Abstract:As generations of artists, historians, and scientists have discovered before us, accurate perspective is difficult to achieve, especially when the observer is too close to their subject.We tend to view the tremendous progress and sophistication of the field of neuromodulation as would a parent, eyeing with love and admiration their beautiful young child, oblivious to the fact that others are staring disdainfully at the demanding, whining brat in front of them. Many of us view the progress in neuromodulation as unparalleled; science fiction becomes a reality as a result of rapidly increasing technologic sophistication and focused research. Unfortunately, this is where our perspective may fail us; a realistic evaluation of where we stand relative to other technologies is required as part of the critical selfassessment of our field and its future.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?