Effects of Music, Massage, Exercise, or Acupuncture in the Treatment of Depression Among College Students: A Network Meta-Analysis
Fang-Bo Li,Ping Lu,Hai-Tao Wu,Ming-Han Wang,Jing-Dong Wang,Fang-bo Li,Hai-tao Wu,Ming-han Wang,Jing-dong Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/NDT.S416643
IF: 2.989
2023-08-02
Neuropsychiatric Disease and Treatment
Abstract:Fang-bo Li, 1, &ast Ping Lu, 2, &ast Hai-tao Wu, 1 Ming-han Wang, 1 Jing-dong Wang 1 1 Graduate School, Guangzhou Sport University, Guangzhou, Guangdong, 510500, People's Republic of China; 2 School of PE and Health, Guangzhou University of Chinese Medicine, Guangzhou, Guangdong, 510006, People's Republic of China &astThese authors contributed equally to this work Correspondence: Fang-bo Li, Graduate School, Guangzhou Sport University, Linhe West Road, Tianhe District, Guangzhou, Guangdong, 510500, People's Republic of China, Tel +86 18860292906, Email Objective: To assess the therapeutic impacts of exercise, massage, and music interventions on college students experiencing depression by employing a mesh meta-analysis approach. This research intends to offer valuable insights to aid in the development of non-pharmaceutical treatment strategies for depression. Methods: We conducted a thorough search across various databases including Cochrane, PubMed, Embase, Web of Science, CNKI, and Wanfang to explore the effects of music, massage, aerobic exercise, fitness Qigong, yoga, tai chi, ball games, strength training, dance, whole body vibration training, and high-intensity interval training on the treatment of depression in college students. The search period was from January 1, 2023, which marks the establishment of each database. Subsequently, a mesh meta-analysis was performed using the "Stata 15.1" software, incorporating outcome indicators from 24 included literature comprising a total of 1458 patients. Results: Based on the ranking of the optimal intervention effects of various non-pharmaceutical methods, the order, from highest to lowest probability, was as follows: high-intensity interval training (96%), yoga (94.90%), dance (78.30%), music (73.30%), ball games (62.50%), strength training (51.70%), aerobic training (45.30%), tai chi (35.40%), vibration training (27.30%), massage (20.10%), qigong (14.30%), and no intervention (1.00%). This ranking aligns closely with the findings obtained from pairwise comparisons between different interventions. Conclusion: High-intensity interval training is likely to yield the most effective therapeutic results for college students with depression. In the pairwise comparison of different interventions, High-intensity interval training is also better than most interventions. However, to establish its intervention effect more conclusively, further validation through additional high-quality randomized controlled trials is necessary. Keywords: depression, music, exercise, college student, network meta-analysis Depression is a common and serious mental health concern among college and university students. 1 The 2019 Global Burden of Illness, Injury, and Risk Factors study showed that depression is one of the most disabling mental disorders, and among adolescents, depression ranked fourth on the list of the world's leading causes of burden in 2019. 2 Studies have shown that depression has become a major emotional problem among college students. College students in their early adulthood are prone to emotional dysregulation and despair. 3 In 2021, China's Ministry of Education requested for the first time that depression screening be included among students' physical examinations, demonstrating that the harm of depression in college students has piqued the state and society's attention. 4 In this context, how to provide effective non-drug treatment to improve depressive symptoms for patients with depression has attracted the attention and research of many researchers. Non-drug treatment methods for depression are currently exercise intervention, music intervention, meditation, acupuncture, massage, and so on. Studies have found that aerobic exercise, traditional Chinese sports (fitness qigong, tai chi, etc.), and meditation can effectively improve the depressive symptoms of college students. 1 Music, massage, and acupuncture have also been proven to be effective in the treatment of depression. 5–9 Several interventions have been evaluated individually or in comparison using randomized controlled trials. 5,10–13 However, there are only a few studies comparing the efficacy of multiple non-pharmacological interventions in network meta-analysis. Therefore, four interventions (exercise, music, massage, and acupuncture) that are regularly utilized in the treatment of depression among college students were selected as research objects. The network meta-analysis method was used to integrate the relevant clinical evidence of direct and indirect comparison. The different interventions of the same evidence were summarized, q -Abstract Truncated-
psychiatry,clinical neurology