The conceit of curriculum

C. Whitehead,A. Kuper,F. Webster

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2923.2012.04245.x

2012-06-01

Medical Education

Abstract:Prescriptions for curricular reform abound in the medical education literature. As a community of educators, we delight in dialogue and reflection on our curricular experiments. This makes good sense, for if we can find more interesting, efficient or relevant ways to help our trainees to develop into competent professionals, we obviously want to do so. The author of the article ‘Improving cultural competence education: the utility of an intersectional framework’, published in this edition of the journal, contributes to robust curriculum development with her recognition of the need for theoretically derived curricula in the area of cultural competence. Powell Sears examines the introduction of cultural competence education in US medical schools. She notes that studies of cultural competence programmes have as yet demonstrated little positive impact. Limited success to date, she suggests, relates to the use of overly simplistic approaches to culture. She proposes that the failure to recognise race as but one of many possible socially constructed aspects of identity contributes to the reproduction of stereotypes. Powell Sears advocates the use of the intersectional framework to provide medical trainees with a more sophisticated understanding of how patients occupy various social locations.