Dead Donors and the "Shortage" of Human Organs: Are We Missing the Point?

B. Koenig

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1162/152651603321611890

2003-03-01

Abstract:without being struck by the ethical reality that there seems to be a moral obligation (not just a charitable hope) that the newly dead should donate. This moral obligation points to a deeper problem, one that remains unaddressed while ethicists and public ofacials quibble over what conditions qualify for organ donation: the demand that we confront squarely the morally obligatory pull that donation holds for us should our bodies be found to be in a condition (whether brain death or— as Koppelman suggests—PVS) that allows for successful transplantation. While accepting that this moral obligation would not do away with a concern for when death occurs and what “states” are acceptable for organ procurement to be considered, if my suspicions are correct, Koppelman and others will need to realize that publicpolicy considerations might arst need to deal with questions of how to get people to fulall this vital moral responsibility at the end of life2 before dealing with what constitutes “death” or, for that matter, “respect.” ■