Lost in translation: Challenges for translational research in the field of stress and cognition.
Israel Liberzon
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biopsych.2024.03.018
IF: 12.81
2024-04-07
Biological Psychiatry
Abstract:Exposure to an adverse environment often compromises an individual's well-being and poses long-term risk for mental and physical disorders. These adverse effects are thought to be mediated by a set of general (stressor non-specific) psychological, biological, and behavioral mechanisms, referred to as "stress" or the "stress-response". The mechanistic/causative link between the stressors (environmental agents causing stress), the stress response, and changes taking place in the organism, has been a topic of vigorous investigations for physicians, psychologists, biologists, and social scientists for nearly a century. Since the seminal work of Hans Selye (1), scientists have been trying to understand "stress effects" but they have been continuously challenged by the complexity and heterogeneity of organisms and their regulatory systems. Selye's seminal contribution was in identifying "general" or "non-specific" aspects of stress responses, but scientific progress has revealed remarkable diversity and specificity in: context, species, sex, age, exposure, tissue, cell, and outcomes, defying easy generalization or reduction to simple principles. Whether we blame the original concept of a single underlying process or the amazing biological/behavior complexity, the search for the holy grail continues. Things become even more complex when we consider the effects of stress on cognition. Like the concept of stress, "cognition" resists any single overarching description. In pursuit of mechanistic links, and in the tradition of original stress research, the field adopted multiple animal models where some parameters can be fixed, others readily manipulated, and ethical questions can be minimized. This process however, while fruitful and even critical for examination of specific mechanisms, ran into major issues related to cross-species differences, anthropomorphism, developmental differences and more. In the following paragraphs I will describe some of the specific challenges in further detail, to help us better appreciate both the progress made and remaining challenges.
neurosciences,psychiatry