Abstract:Background: CAR T cells for the treatment of solid tumor cancers has not yet achieved the same success as CAR T cells for treatment of blood cancers. Two of the hurdles that must be cleared for effective use of CAR T cells for solid tumor cancers are: 1) CAR T cell exhaustion; and 2) failure to recognize and kill low antigen expressing cancer cells. A promising approach to overcoming CAR T cell exhaustion, referred to as "1XX" was developed in the Sadelain Lab at MSKCC. Mutation of Tyrosines to Phenylalanine in ITAMs 2 and 3, of the CD3z signaling domain, restrict signaling to ITAM 1. This slowing down of signaling has been reported to be effective at eliminating or greatly reducing CAR T cell exhaustion in blood cancers [Feucht, et al 2019; Park et al 2022; Schoutrop, et al 2023]. Purpose: To evaluate the potential of the 1XX mutations to overcome CAR T cell exhaustion and inability to kill low antigen expressing cells in an animal model of breast cancer. Specifically, we tested the ability of three different CARs to eliminate human breast tumors that expressed variable levels of the target antigen, MUC1*, and their ability to suppress tumor recurrence over approximately 100 days. Methods: All three CARs were targeted to the tumor by the same antibody fragment, huMNC2, that recognizes MUC1*, which is the transmembrane cleavage product of MUC1 that functions as a potent growth factor receptor. The CARs are: 1) huMNC2-41BB-CD3z; 2) huMNC2-CD28-CD3z; and 3) huMNC2-CD28-1XX. Heterogeneous tumors expressing different levels of target antigen were made as follows. T47D breast cancer cells were engineered to express even more of the target, MUC1*, and were also engineered to fluoresce green. T47D wild type cells were engineered to fluoresce red. Heterogenous tumors consisting of 250,000 cells were implanted sub-cu into female NSG mice bearing 90-day estrogen pellets. The tumors comprised either 70% wild-type/30% overexpressing cells, or 85% wild-type/15% overexpressing cells or 92.5% wild-type/7.5% overexpressing cells. Tumor engraftment was verified by bioluminescence at Day 6 post implantation. There was a total of 150 animals, 5 animals per group. Animals were administered a single dose of CAR T cells into the tail vein on Day 7, wherein the Effector to Target ratio was either 10:1, 5:1 or 1:1. Tumor volume was measured weekly by Luciferase/Luciferin bioluminescence on an IVIS instrument. In addition, the red versus green fluorescence of the tumor was tracked periodically as an indicator of which cells, high or low antigen expressing, were being killed. Between Day 93 and Day 96, animals were sacrificed, cells were recovered from blood and spleen, recovered tumors were weighed, tumor cells dissociated and fluorescent images were captured to determine which cells escaped CAR T cell killing. Conclusions: The CAR with the 1XX mutations in CD3z, huMNC2-CD28-1XX, was much more effective at suppressing breast tumor recurrence than either CAR with wild-type CD3z. At sacrifice, significantly more CAR T cells were recovered from huMNC2-CD28-1XX than from huMNC2-41BB-CD3z or huMNC2-CD28-CD3z. At high dose, the CARs with wild-type CD3z effectively suppressed the high antigen expressing cells, but the recurrent tumors were essentially made up of the low antigen expressing cells that had escaped CAR T cell killing. At low CAR T cell dose, the CARs with wild-type CD3z appeared to become exhausted about 40 days post treatment, when tumors began to recur. Post sacrifice analysis of the recurrent tumors showed that they were made up of both high and low antigen expressing cells. huMNC2-CD28-1XX effectively killed both the high antigen and low antigen expressing cells as evidenced by the live fluorescent imaging and the post-sacrifice analysis of residual tumor. Citation Format: Cynthia Bamdad, Andrew Stewart, Benoit Smagghe, Mark Carter, Danica Walkley, Kevin Yi, Jac-Leen Nash, Michael Nash, Trevor Grant, Gregory Riley. Animal Study Compares CAR T cell Exhaustion & Ability to Kill Low Antigen expressing breast cancer cells among three CAR constructs including one with 1XX mutations [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the 2023 San Antonio Breast Cancer Symposium; 2023 Dec 5-9; San Antonio, TX. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2024;84(9 Suppl) nr PO1-26-05.

Abstract 5342: Evaluation of autologous and allogeneic T cell-based therapies in ex-vivo and in-vivo xenograft tumor models

Abstract 6787: Evaluation of CAR-T cytotoxicity in solid tumors: A screening workflow using 3D patient-derived tumoroids

Abstract 4216: Indication agnostic evaluation of CAR T cell function using patient-derived immunocompetent tumoroid modelling platform

Abstract 5242: In vitro cytotoxicity assays to support CAR T cell evaluation against solid tumors

Abstract 4256: Autologous organoids and T cell co-cultures as a powerful personalized platform for immunotherapy development

Abstract 6766: Assessing the impact of immunotherapies and cell therapies in 3D heterospheroid models mimicking tumor microenvironments

Abstract 4020: Donor-dependent anti-tumoral efficacy of human CD19 CAR T cells in a leukemic xenograft mouse model

Abstract 697: Enhanced tumor control and survival in solid tumor models following combined low dose radiotherapy and T cell therapy

Abstract 2814: Anti-CAIX Immune Restoring (IR) CAR-T cells display superior antitumor activity and reverse immunosuppressive TME in a humanized ccRCC orthotopic mouse model

Abstract LB344: A novel approach to limit off-tumor toxicity of CAR-T cells targeting solid cancers

Abstract 3975: A therapeutic screening platform for assessing antigen-specific T cell-mediated tumor killing in vitro

Abstract 4703: Automated 42 PDX 3D in vitro tumor models of the TME screen immuno-oncology and targeted compounds and biologics for antitumor effects and MOA

Enhanced tumor control and survival in preclinical models with adoptive cell therapy preceded by low-dose radiotherapy

Abstract PO1-26-05: Animal Study Compares CAR T cell Exhaustion & Ability to Kill Low Antigen expressing breast cancer cells among three CAR constructs including one with 1XX mutations

Abstract 1435: Utilization of CLDN18.2 syngeneic mouse models to study chimeric antigen receptor T cells in immunocompetent mice

Abstract LB071: Weaponizing CAR T-cells to attack PD-L1 presenting cells in solid tumors

Abstract 4575: High-throughput method to analyze the cytotoxicity of CAR T cells in a 3D tumor spheroid model using image cytometry

Abstract 4018: An innovative in vivo model for CAR-T cell therapy development: Tolerability and efficacy evaluation of CD19-targeting CAR-T cells on human lymphoma using the chicken CAM assay

Abstract 5362: AI-enabled novel workflow to evaluate T-cell activity in vitro using 3D spheroid models

Abstract B040: High-Content Screening to Enhance the Preclinical Development of Immunotherapies, Validated for 100 Patient-Derived Organoids

Abstract B079: Human 3D ovarian cancer models reveal malignant cell intrinsic and extrinsic factors that influence CAR-T cell activity