Abstract:Forest–grassland ecotones, the transitional zones between forests and grasslands, often harbor high levels of biodiversity. According to the portfolio theory, communities with such high biodiversity should exhibit high stability in ecosystem functioning. On the contrary, the theory of ‘bi-stability’ or ‘multistability’ predicts that ecosystems exhibiting multiple states or regimes (e.g. forest and grassland) are less stable. Understanding the stability of forest–grassland ecotone has broad implications for forest management and restoration. In this study, by quantifying landscape heterogeneity and temporal invariability of regional climatic and vegetational metrics, we aimed to reveal how landscape diversity influences the stability of ecosystem functioning in the forest–grassland ecotone. We focused on the forest–grassland ecotone in northern China (i.e. from the forest belt in the Greater Khingan Mountains to the steppe grassland in Inner Mongolia) and used remote sensing data of land cover dynamics from 1992 to 2015 to analyze the landscape diversity and ecosystem dynamics at different grain sizes. To measure the temporal stability of climatic variables and vegetational dynamics, we calculated the interannual variation of temperature (T), wind speed (WS), precipitation (P), and the net primary productivity (NPP) on the grided sampling cells at different spatial scale over the same period. Our results showed that landscape diversity across this forest–grassland ecotone was positively related to the stability of T and NPP, but negatively related to that of WS and P. These opposite patterns may be explained by the differential nature of ecosystem variables, namely whether they involve transporting substance across space (WS and P) or not (T and NPP). We also found that as the spatial scale increases, the diversity-stability relationships strengthened for all three climatic variables (i.e., T, P, WS). However, the stabilizing effects of landscape diversity on NPP first increased but then decreased with increasing grain size, peaking at 30 km. Our empirical analyses demonstrate strong, but context-dependent diversity-stability relationships, shedding light on the paradox in the stability of ecosystem functioning in the ecotone. These findings also have implications for the management of landscape resources to maintain the sustainability of forest–grassland ecotones.

Significant implications of diversity and stability for ecosystem sustainability necessitate differentiated management strategies: A case study of the urban agglomeration around Hangzhou Bay, China

Long-Term Spatiotemporal Changes in Ecosystem Services Caused by Coastal Wetland Type Transformation in China’s Hangzhou Bay

Multiscale Ecological Zoning Management with Coupled Ecosystem Service Bundles and Supply–Demand Balance, the Case of Hangzhou, China

Assessment and Management Zoning of Ecosystem Service Trade-Off/Synergy Based on the Social–Ecological Balance: A Case of the Chang-Zhu-Tan Metropolitan Area

Coupling Coordination Development of the Ecological–Economic System in Hangzhou, China

The rapid prosperity of China's Pearl River Delta from the perspective of social–ecological coupling: implications for sustainable management

Spatial-temporal variation, driving mechanism and management zoning of ecological resilience based on RSEI in a coastal metropolitan area

Cities and Urbanization: Balancing the Environmental and Socioeconomic Dimensions of Sustainability

Land use and river-lake connectivity: Biodiversity determinants of lake ecosystems

Coastal Wetland Restoration Strategies Based on Ecosystem Service Changes: A Case Study of the South Bank of Hangzhou Bay

Multilevel driving mechanism of ecosystem multidimensional stability in the Yangtze River Economic Belt: A hierarchical linear model approach

Integrating Sustainability Assessment Into Decoupling Analysis: A Focus On The Yangtze River Delta Urban Agglomerations

Hierarchical analysis of landscape urbanization and its impacts on regional sustainability: A case study of the Yangtze River Economic Belt of China

Towards Sustainable Management of Urban Ecological Space: A Zoning Approach Hybridized by Ecosystem Service Value and Ecological Risk Assessment

Exploring Ecosystem Sensitivity Patterns in China: A Quantitative Analysis Using the Importance-Vulnerability-Sensitivity Framework and Neighborhood Effects Method

Stable or Unstable? Landscape Diversity and Ecosystem Stability Across Scales in the Forest–grassland Ecotone in Northern China

Mapping ecological space quality changes for ecological management: A case study in the Pearl River Delta urban agglomeration, China

Analysis of Factors Influencing Plant Diversity in Urban Wetlands Based on a Structural Equation Model

Land Use Zoning Management to Coordinate the Supply–Demand Imbalance of Ecosystem Services: A Case Study in the City Belt Along the Yellow River in Ningxia, China

Coupling and Coordination Relationship between Urbanization Quality and Ecosystem Services in the Upper Yellow River: A Case Study of the Lanzhou–Xining Urban Agglomeration, China

Differential Evaluation of Ecological Resilience in 45 Cities along the Yangtze River in China: A New Multidimensional Analysis Framework