Y-CHROMOSOME DE NOVO RECOMBINANTS. IMPLICATIONS FOR NOMENCLATURE.
H. Rivera
Abstract:In our report on a de novo rea (21) in this journal (3), we characterize this and other similar composites as recombinant-like chromosomes because their segmental composition is akin to that of a classical recombinant resulting from a meiotic crossing-over in a pericentric inversion carrier. We subsequently compiled 104 cases involving most autosomes and the X-chromosome (10) but failed to include four similar Y-chromosomes described as "rare rearrangements" or derivatives (1, 2, 8, 11). More recently, four further Y-pseudoisochromosomes were published (6, 7, 13). Noticeably, these eight asymmetric monocentric de novo Y-chromosomes entail dup p/del q or vice versa and are indistinguishable from true recombinants.For the sake of completeness, I mention a comparable dup p/del q compound imbalance found in an infertile male who had both a de novo interstitial AZFb deletion and an intra-arm Yp duplication inherited from his fertile father (12). Clearly, the structure of this unique chromosome sets it apart from the recombinant-like Y-chromosomes here reviewed; actually, it is a genuine derivative resulting from two rearrangements within a single chromosome (5).Both rea(Y)dup p or pseudoisoYp (1, 2,6, 7, 11) and rea(Y)dup q or pseudoisoYq (8,13) chromosomes further support the contention that de novo recombinant-like chromosomes do not ensue from an undiagnosed parental or germinal pericentric inversion (10); rather, they seemingly result from intra-chromosomal non-allelic homologous recombination (6).Taken together, the eight rec(Y) chromosomes here compiled challenge the narrow ISCN definition of recombinant as a rearranged chromosome "resulting from meiotic crossing-over... in certain types of structural heterozygotes" (5). Indeed, that definition should be expanded to encompass constitutional de novo recombinants including those arisen from the Y or any single chromosome and regardless of the underlying mechanism. Or, if the restriction to classic meiotic crossing-over were essential, then the abbreviation rea may be appropriate (3, 10).To conclude, I stress the academic and moral duty that authors, reviewers, editors, and readers have to assembly complete bibliographies and supply missing references (4,9).[Reference]REFERENCES1. CHOIE. X, LEE B. X, PARK J. X, LEE X W. OHA.R., LEE S. X, KIMS. X, HAN Y.J., LEE M.B.. RYUH.M., SEO J.T., PARK S.X: Monocentric derivative Y chromosome with duplication of the SRY gene in an azoospermie male. J. Genet. Med., 2010,7,160-164.2. CUI Y.-X., SHI Y.-C., LIU Q., XIAX.-Y, LU H.-Y., SHAO H-F, JIA L, YAO B" GE Y.-F., LI X.-J., HUANG Y-F: A case of agonadism associated with Y-chromosome rearrangement: cytogenetic and molecular studies. J. Androl., 2009,30,650-654.3. DOMINGUEZ M.G., ARTEAGA-ALCARAZ G" RIVERA H.: Pure duplication 21q21. …