Abstract:The purpose of this qualitative systematic review was to examine how frailty was conceptually and operationally defined for participant inclusion in qualitative research focused on the lived experience of frailty in community-living frail older adults. Search of six electronic databases, 1994–2019, yielded 25 studies. Data collection involved extracting the definition of frailty from the study aim, background, literature review, methods, and sampling strategy in each research study. Quality appraisal indicated that 13 studies (52%) demonstrated potential researcher bias based on insufficient information about participant recruitment, sampling, and relationship between the researcher and participant. Content analysis and concept mapping were applied for data synthesis. Although frailty was generally defined as a multidimensional, biopsychosocial construct with loss of resilience and vulnerability to adverse outcomes, most studies defined the study population based on older age and physical impairments derived from subjective assessment by the researcher, a healthcare professional, or a family member. However, 13 studies (52%) used objective or performance-based quantitative measures to classify participant frailty. There was no consistency across studies in standardized measures or objective assessment of frailty. Synthesis of the findings yielded four themes: Time, Vulnerability, Loss, and Relationships. The predominance of older age and physical limitations as defining characteristics of frailty raises questions about whether participants were frail, since many older adults at advanced age and with physical limitations are not frail. Lack of clear criteria to classify frailty and reliance on subjective assessment introduces the risk for bias, threatens the validity and interpretation of findings, and hinders transferability of findings to other contexts. Clear frailty inclusion and exclusion criteria and a standardized approach in the reporting of how frailty is conceptually and operationally defined in study abstracts and the methodology used is necessary to facilitate dissemination and development of metasynthesis studies that aggregate qualitative research findings that can be used to inform future research and applications in clinical practice to improve healthcare.

Understanding frailty and its opposites from community-dwelling older peoples' perspectives: A phenomenological qualitative study

Older people's perception of being frail – a qualitative exploration

Understanding Frailty: Perspectives and Experiences of Rural Older Adults in India

The lived experience of frailty: beyond classification and towards a holistic understanding of health

Associations between lifestyle factors and multidimensional frailty: a cross-sectional study among community-dwelling older people

Interplay of Physical, Psychological, and Social Frailty among Community-Dwelling Older Adults in Five European Countries: A Longitudinal Study

The frail older person does not exist: development of frailty profiles with latent class analysis

Looking out across the front yard: aboriginal peoples' views of frailty in the community - A qualitative study

A Hybrid Concept Analysis of Frailty Among Older Adults Living in the Community

Definitions of Frailty in Qualitative Research: A Qualitative Systematic Review

Defining and assessing psychological frailty in older adults: a scoping review protocol

Constructions of frailty in the English language, care practice and the lived experience

Current Perspectives on Frailty in the Elderly, Evaluation Tools and Care Pathways

Association between physical, psychological and social frailty and health-related quality of life among older people

The association between loneliness and frailty among community-dwelling older adults in five European countries: a longitudinal study

The Association between Frailty, Quality of Life and Resilience in Community-dwelling Retirement Village Residents

Towards an integral conceptual model of frailty

The impact of frailty on the use of social services, medication and mortality risk: a cross-sectional study

The Complexity of Frailty: Psychological Mechanism and Therapeutic Interventions in Old People - A Narrative Review

Perspectives of Frailty and Frailty Screening: Protocol for a Collaborative Knowledge Translation Approach and Qualitative Study of Stakeholder Understandings and Experiences

A Qualitative Exploration of Older Patients' Experiences With Frailty and Related Management Strategies