Energising a faculty medical education retreat with liberating structures

H. Chumley,D. Magrane
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2923.2011.03961.x
2011-05-01
Medical Education
Abstract:programme is transported from one country to another, it is important to ascertain whether it caters to local needs and wants. The current study was conducted to establish whether the expectations of Indian applicants to the fellowship programme matched the objectives of the programme. What was done In the course of their application to the FAIMER regional institute fellowship programme in India, applicants were asked why they were applying for the fellowship. Answers to this question from 55 applicants selected for the 2009 fellowship programme at the three regional institutes were analysed. Coding was performed by one researcher and the codes were verified and validated by another until a consensus was reached. In addition, focus group discussions were conducted at the end of Year 1 of the fellowship to further elicit participant viewpoints. Evaluation of results and impact The major themes to emerge referred to the desire to acquire knowledge or skills in specific areas, the desire to bring about a specific change or make a difference, career advancement, the need to network, previous experience in medical education and previous awareness of the fellowship programme. Applicants most frequently described their need to acquire the specific knowledge (44%) and pedagogic skills to become effective teachers (78%) and good trainers of medical teachers (38%). They specifically wanted to learn about educational methods, assessment, curriculum design, communication skills, mentoring, and educational and scientific research methodology. They also wrote about their desires to bring about specific curricular innovations (40%), improve the health system in their country (38%), strengthen their medical education units (26%) and improve the quality of teaching imparted by their institutes (25%). They articulated their need to network with international and national medical educationalists (31%) and their desire to acquire a formal degree in medical education or some other form of recognition (20%). They also described the influence of past exposure or experiences in medical education (38%) and reported having been made aware by colleagues of the quality of the FAIMER programme (11%) and the impressive quality of its faculty staff (13%). Although results indicate some alignment between expectations and objectives, most applicants expected the curriculum to cover topics related to teaching and learning methods (51%) and assessment (26%), rather than leadership (10%) or management (7%). This may be explained by the applicants’ low level of awareness of the leadership and management components at the time of application. The results of the focus group discussion showed that participants’ appreciation of the importance of these topics increased after they were enrolled in the fellowship programme. Matching learner expectations and needs with educational content is important and educational programmes can expand learners’ horizons.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?