Specters, Traces, and Regret in Ethics Consultation

P. Ford,Denise M. Dudzinski
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/JCE200516302
2005-09-01
Abstract:As clinical ethics consultants, we inevitably participate in cases that haunt us long after our formal involvement ends. With patients, families, and careproviders, we are moral agents who are culpable for our interactions and our recommendations. When we consult, we weave ourselves into the story of the case. In doing so, we influence the path of the story and are altered by the encounter. The standard way to write an ethics case is to focus on a particular ethical issue, rather than the role of the consultant in the case and the impact of the case on the ethics consultant. There are times when no good solution exists, when organizational or legal constraints seem insurmountable, and/or the consultant is unable to bring about the result that she or he desires. Although we need to discuss patients’ ethical dilemmas for their own sake, we must also share the affective nature of complex situations. In trying to act with integrity, we strive to recognize our shortcomings and to improve our practices. Having the courage to write about these cases is important for helping new people in the field, because these expositions highlight the personal and professional risks of ethics consultation. Sharing haunting cases may improve the practice of clinical ethics consultation by addressing the character and professional development of consultants. Ethics consultants influence how cases play out, if in no other way than to bring greater understanding of individual and professional values, fostering decision making. While clinical ethics consultants may encourage others to courageously express and negotiate values, consultants also risk harming others and being harmed themselves.1 To practice ethics consultation well, we invest ourselves in the devastating circumstances of others, and we genuinely want to Specters, Traces, and Regret in Ethics Consultation
What problem does this paper attempt to address?