Hinged external fixator combined with internal fixation in the treatment of complex elbow fractures
Li-song HENG,Yang-jun ZHU,Kun ZHANG,Jun ZHANG,Hong-hao DUAN
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1009-4237.2017.07.004
2017-01-01
Abstract:Objective To explore the effect of hinged external fixator combined with internal fixation in the treatment of complex elbow fractures.Methods From May 2010 to Mar.2015,46 patients with complex elbow fractures were treated and analyzed retrospectively.Among them,26 patients underwent external fixation combined with external fixator (external fixator group),including terrible triad of the elbow in 12 cases,anti Monteggia fracture in 6 cases,and olecranon fracture and dislocation in 8 cases;20 patients were treated with internal fixation combined with adjustable protector (adjustable protector group),including terrible triad of the elbow in 10 cases,anti Monteggia fracture in 5 cases,and olecranon fracture and dislocation in 5 cases.All patients underwent open reduction and internal fixation.The external fixator group was fixed with the hinged external fixator,and the adjustable protector group was treated with adjustable protector after internal fixation.The elbow function was evaluated at the last follow-up by Mayo elbow performance score (MEPS).Results All the 46 patients were followed up for 10 to 24 months (average,16.8 months).All the patients obtained bone union.The healing time of the external fixator group was (12.6±2.4) weeks,and the healing time of the adjustable protector group was (13.8±3.6) weeks,without significant difference between the two groups (P>0.05).At the last follow-up,for the external fixator group,the flexion and extension angle of the elbow joint was 129.98°±12.59°,the rotation angle of the forearm was 142.15°±15.35°,and the average MEPS was 91 points (58-96 points).The MEPS results indicated excellent in 21 cases,good in 2 cases,fair in 2 cases,and poor in 1 case,with the excellent and good rate of 88.5%.For the adjustable protector group,the flexion and extension angle was 106.98°±10.36°(56°-112°),the rotation angle was 121.32°±17.67°(64°-127°),and the average MEPS was 82 points (55-92 points).The MEPS results indicated excellent in 10 cases,good in 4 cases,fair in 2 cases,and poor in 4 cases,with the excellent and good rate of 70.0%.All the indicators had significant differences between the two groups(P<0.05).Conclusion The internal fixation combined with hinged external fixation can get better functional recovery for complex elbow fracture.