Clinical Examination as Medicolegal Proof of Alcohol Intoxication

A. Penttilä,M. Tenhu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/002580247601600205
1976-04-01
Abstract:INTRODUCTION Clinical examination of intoxication due to alcohol or another narcotic can be defined as a method in which several simple tests which describe the operation of various psychomoto­ r s functions are utilized, a n d test results are Used for drawing conclusions about the degree of intoxication and used for medico­ legal and juridical purposes. During the past two decades less attention has been paid to clinical examination. This is obviously because it is in general accepted that the result of a clinical examination is dependent on so many different factors derived from the person to be examined, the examining physician and the examination method, that the examination result is, there­ fore, thought to be unreliable. The contro­ versial results obtained with a clinical examination and blood alcohol test and appearing repeatedly in practice (Rasch, 1969) are the strongest argument for these Complaints. T h e above-mentioned has also heen the obvious reason for the latest develop­ ment in numerous countries where one or ^wo fixed blood alcohol limit values are included in the legislation in order to make the medicolegal examination and punishment °f intoxicated persons more uniform. The same trend has also been character­ ise of recent literature in the field. Dur ing the forties and fifties much attention was Paid to various aspects of the clinical exami­ nation and the last review article by Elbel a n d Schleyer (1956) on this subject dates
What problem does this paper attempt to address?