Hematohidrosis in 15th Century Renaissance Art and a Review of Modern Literature
Shyer Wern Goh,Wen Hon Darren Wee,Wen Xin Rachel Chua,Bingwen Eugene Fan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1055/s-0043-1768937
2023-05-17
Seminars in Thrombosis and Hemostasis
Abstract:Hematohidrosis, or hematidrosis, is a rare medical condition characterized by blood oozing from the intact skin in the absence of a bleeding problem.[1] Prior to modern-day medical literature, these phenomena had been captured in Renaissance and also present-day artwork. While the purpose of medical literature is to aid healthcare professionals and patients in the better understanding and treatment of disease, a significant proportion of Renaissance art commissioned by the church depicted scenes from the Bible, for the purposes of a visual depiction of key events to promote teachings of the faith, and to encourage devotion to God. We explored the theme of hematohidrosis in historic art and performed a rapid review of modern medical literature, noting that the earliest works featuring hematohidrosis were depictions in Renaissance art as early as the 15th century. The German painter known as Meister Der Freisinger Passion (Master of the Freising Passion) depicts Jesus Christ in the Garden of Gethsemane at the foot of the Mount of Olives, sweating drops of blood ([Fig. 1]). Around him, his disciples sit, fast asleep. Another piece given the same name, the Christus am Ölberg , is featured in one of the frescoes of the Tabernakelbildstock in Welsberg-Taisten (Wayside Shrine of Tesido; [Fig. 2]). Believed to have been painted by Wolfgang Sauber in the 1460s, it depicts Christ with his hands clasped together in prayer as bloody sweat dots his forehead. These two artworks provide visual testimony to Luke's account of the Gospel of Jesus Christ praying in the Garden of Gethsemane before crucifixion. The motif of the cup is featured in the two artworks, echoing Christ's words in Luke 22:42, "Father, if you are willing, remove this cup from me. Nevertheless, not My will, but Yours, be done." The cup is a symbol of the cup of God's wrath that Jesus takes upon Himself, as He takes on the sins of the nations. In the words of preacher Charles Spurgeon, "at one tremendous draught of love, He drank damnation dry." Luke tells us that "being in agony, He prayed more earnestly; and His sweat became like great drops of blood falling down to the ground" (Luke 22:45). This was likely the first documented case report of hematohidrosis in the existing literature. Given Luke's background as a physician, this could possibly explain his attention to medical detail that is otherwise not reported in the other Gospels. In an era where the lay people were largely illiterate and printed Bibles were not largely available till the advent of Johannes Gutenberg's printing press in 1440, religious art was crucial in passing on teachings of the faith, and in encouraging reflection on Biblical events and devotion to God. Despite its rarity, several cases of hematohidrosis have been reported globally and reviewed in the literature in recent years. We performed a search for "hematohidrosis," "haematohidrosis," "hematidrosis," or "haematidrosis" in PubMed for articles published up to January 2023. We excluded cases with chromhidrosis, a rare condition with a presentation of the secretion of colored sweat secondary to dyes, drugs, chromogenic bacteria, fungi, and chemical contactants. Cases of hemolacria (presence of blood in tears), as well as mucosal bleeding (i.e., bleeding from the nose, tongue, or intestinal bleeding), as a single, exclusive site of bleeding were excluded, as these surfaces do not contain sweat glands. Cases presenting only with otorrhagia (bleeding from the ear) were also excluded. Our preliminary search results comprised 64 articles, of which 42 were included; these yielded 4 case series and 38 case reports with the earliest report from 1918, with most of the cases published in 2008 to 2023 ([Table 1]). A total of 22 articles were excluded, of which 11 articles were in non-English languages, 7 were literature reviews without new case reports, 1 report was on a dog, 1 was a patient with Henoch Schonlein purpura presenting with bloody sweats, 1 was a sole presentation of hemolacria, and 1 article presented four cases of otorrhagia. In total, 48 cases of hematohidrosis were identified from the 42 articles; these comprised predominantly of females (38; 79.2%), with a median age of 12 years, with a trend toward younger patients, with the youngest patient being 2 months, with the majority of patients (41; 81.4%) being younger than 21 years ([Table 2]). A significant proportion of cases originated in India and more specifically in Asia, with few cases from Europe and North America, which was a trend also observed by Kluger.[2] There seems to be increasing literature on hematohidrosis (given the tempo of case reports published) as noted by Duffin,[3] when comparing articles published between 1880 and 1935, and 1952 and 2016. As compared with 76 cases analyzed by Holoubek and Holoubek in 1996 (many of which were from be -Abstract Truncated-
peripheral vascular disease,hematology