Abstract:Objectives: To study surgical teaching captured on film and analyze it at a fine level of detail to categorize physical teaching behaviors. Design: We describe live, filmed, intraoperative nonverbal exchanges between surgical attending physicians and their trainees (residents and fellows). From the films, we chose key teaching moments and transcribed participants' utterances, actions, and gestures. In follow-up interviews, attending physicians and trainees watched videos of their teaching case and answered open-ended questions about their teaching methods. Using a grounded theory approach, we examined the videos and interviews for what might be construed as a teaching behavior and refined the physical teaching categories through constant comparison. Setting: We filmed 5 cases in the operating suite of a university teaching hospital that provides gynecologic surgical care. Participants: We included 5 attending gynecologic surgeons, 3 fellows, and 5 residents for this study. Results: More than 6 hours of film and 3 hours of interviews were transcribed, and more than 250 physical teaching motions were captured. Attending surgeons relied on actions and gestures, sometimes wordlessly, to achieve pedagogical and surgical goals simultaneously. Physical teaching included attending physician-initiated actions that required immediate corollary actions from the trainee, gestures to illustrate a step or indicate which instrument to be used next, supporting or retracting tissues, repositioning the trainee's instruments, and placement of the attending physicians' hands on the trainees' hands to guide them. Attending physicians often voiced surprise at the range of their own teaching behaviors captured on film. Interrater reliability was high using the Cohen κ, which was 0.76 for the physical categories. Conclusions: Physical guidance is essential in educating a surgical trainee, may be tacit, and is not always accompanied by speech. Awareness of teaching behaviors may encourage deliberate teaching and reflection on how to innovate pedagogy for the teaching operating room.

Surgeon as teacher Scott Warner Woods Memorial Lecture Midwest Surgical Association Mackinac Island, Michigan

Teaching to transform surgical culture: an educational programme and thematic analysis in a general surgery department

The History of Surgical Education in the United States: Past, Present, and Future

Leading from within: shaping a resident-driven leadership curriculum for surgical trainees using a qualitative needs assessment

How surgical mentors teach: a classification of in vivo teaching behaviors part 2: physical teaching guidance

Doing More with Less: Surgical Training in the COVID-19 Era

Cardiothoracic surgery residency training: past, present, and future

Blue Ribbon Committee II

Perspectives on Surgical Leadership: A Panel Discussion at the Society for Clinical Vascular Surgery

Becoming a "homegrown" surgeon: an applied core skills curriculum and its applicability in the real world

Residents Need a Dynamic Approach to Leadership Education: A Qualitative Study

Operating from the other side of the table: control dynamics and the surgeon educator

How can surgical training benefit from theories of skilled motor development, musical skill acquisition and performance psychology?

Qualitative Methodology for Planning and Executing In-Person and Virtual Neurosurgery Educational Opportunities for Medical Students: Lessons Learned from Five Years of Medical Student Neurosurgery Training Center Initiatives

Surgery Grand Rounds: Perspectives of the 21st Century Attendee

Continuing Education for Global Neurosurgery Graduates: Visiting Surgeons, Skills Teaching, Bootcamps, and Twinning Programs

The importance of an ethics curriculum in surgical education

Importance of multimodal resident education curriculum for general surgeons: perspectives of trainers and trainees

Education of the modern surgical resident: novel approaches to learning in the era of the 80-hour workweek

Preparing Residents to Navigate Neurosurgical Careers in the 21st Century: Implementation of a Yearlong Enhanced Didactics Curriculum

How Educational Theory Can Inform the Training and Practice of Plastic Surgeons