Aristotelian References to the Law of Reflection

C. Boyer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/347917

1946-01-01

Isis

Abstract:IT HAS been said that "only three physical laws were correctly known to the ancients: the law of the lever, the optical law of reflexion, and the law of buoyancy." 1 Oddly enough, however, of these ancient physical laws there is one the origin of which is shrouded in uncertainty. The principle of buoyancy was apparently the discovery of ARCHIMEDES.2 The law of the lever, ubiquitously also ascribed to ARCHIMEDES., nevertheless had appeared clearly and quantitatively expressed in the works of ARISTOTLE.3 As to the law of reflection of light, on the other hand, no clear-cut claim of priority, either as to discovery or publication, appears to be recognized. The law frequently is attributed to HERON OF ALEXANDRIA, whose work in optics long was confused with that of his contemporary PTOLEMY.4 Yet by some we are told that ARCHIMEDES' discovery of the law of the reflection of light is "undisputed";5 and by others we are asured that "the equality of the angles of incidence and reflection was known to EUCLID." 6