Combination of Social Determinants and Improvements in Population Health Outcomes
Brita Roy
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2024.25957
2024-09-01
JAMA Network Open
Abstract:Walker et al 1 apply latent class analysis to integrate multilevel data on known social risk factors to define clusters or phenotypes of these social risk factors. Importantly, they include 26 factors in the domains of socioeconomic status, neighborhood and built environment, food environment, education, social and community context, and psychological and behavioral risk factors in their analysis. They identify 5 unique clusters of social risk factors and assess the associations of each cluster with diabetes-related outcomes, including glycemic control, blood pressure, and quality of life. Clusters varied in their associations with high blood pressure, poor glycemic control, and poor mental health–related quality of life. This study 1 is notable because prior work 2 has shown that the socioeconomic, environmental, behavioral, and psychosocial neighborhood context impacts the health of its residents over and above individual-level risk factors. For example, neighborhood socioeconomic factors have been shown to be associated with cardiovascular health, independently of individual-level socioeconomic factors. 3 In addition, the presence and density of green space and quality of food outlets is associated with behaviors that influence diabetes and other cardiovascular risk factors. 4 Prior research 5 also shows that the neighborhood psychosocial environment—for example, social cohesion, community engagement, and community well-being—influences health long-term cardiometabolic risk. For example, after adjusting for individual-level clinical, behavioral, and socioeconomic risk factors, higher county-level well-being is associated with lower rates of preterm birth. 6 As such, measures of socioeconomic, neighborhood, and psychosocial factors at multiple levels should be included in assessing risk for poor health outcomes. Although these associations have been reported independently, these social risk factors do not exist in isolation. These factors are all associated with structural and systemic racism, as well as mass incarceration, which together influence neighborhood-level and individual-level social risk profiles. Furthermore, these factors are interrelated and have influence over the life course. Recent studies 7 reported that higher neighborhood-level exposure to mass incarceration is associated with lower life expectancy. Another study 8 examining associations between neighborhood factors in childhood and incident hypertension through age 50 years reported that a 1-SD increase in childhood neighborhood incarceration rate was associated with 12% greater odds of incident hypertension in adulthood. Moreover, accounting for childhood neighborhood factors, including incarceration, explained the majority of the racial differences in hypertension onset in adulthood. As such, more fully characterizing the combined risk that individual-level and neighborhood-level social risk factors, at various critical time points in the life course, confers on diabetes and other health outcomes is essential to understanding their true impact. These novel social risk clusters identified by Walker et al 1 are an important first step in defining additional, clinically relevant information on diabetes and cardiometabolic risk that can be used at the individual and population levels. For example, these social risk clusters could be used to inform point-of-care clinical risk scores, as well as more holistic population health program development or community health improvements on the right combination of factors. The latter is advantageous, because intervening on a single social risk factor alone is likely to be insufficient to effectively lower the risk of poor diabetes outcomes. Analogous analyses could be performed to assess associations of these social risk profiles with other health outcomes. Published: August 29, 2024. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2024.25957 Open Access: This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the CC-BY License. © 2024 Roy B. JAMA Network Open . Corresponding Author: Brita Roy, MD, MPH, MHS, Section of Health Equity, Department of Population Health, NYU Grossman School of Medicine, 5800 3rd Ave, Ste 2-004, Brooklyn, NY 11220 (brita.roy@nyulangone.org). Conflict of Interest Disclosures: None reported.
medicine, general & internal