Predicting Functional Outcome After Nonoperative Treatment of Proximal Humeral Fractures Involving the Surgical Neck
Matthijs Jacxsens,Vilijam Zdravkovic,Martin Olach,Elisa Urbani,Bernhard Jost,Christian Spross
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jse.2024.08.034
IF: 3.507
2024-10-20
Journal of Shoulder and Elbow Surgery
Abstract:Background In nonoperative treated proximal humeral fractures (PHF) , uncertainty remains regarding functional outcome. Therefore, the aim was to identify predictors of functional outcome following nonoperative treatment of PHF and to develop predictive models. Methods Adults with a nonoperatively treated PHF involving the surgical neck were followed for 1 year. Radiographic parameters included fracture configuration, displacement, bone quality, and the critical shoulder angle (CSA). The neck-shaft angle (NSA) and humeral head offset assessed displacement. The greater tuberosity index (GTI) addressed greater tuberosity (GT) displacement relative to the articular surface while the impingement index addressed GT-displacement relative to the acromion. Multivariate regression models determined predictors of impaired function as measured by Constant Score (CS), flexion, and external rotation (ER). Recursive partitioning created a decision tree model over dichotomized functional outcome that combined flexion and ER (good = flexion ≥ 120° and ER ≥ 40°). Results In 272 consecutive patients (mean age: 66 years, 69% women and 31% men), mean functional outcomes were a CS of 74 points, 138° flexion, and 50° ER. Older age was a predictor for impaired CS, flexion, and ER (p < 0.001), while sex only influenced CS (p = 0.040). Every 10% increase in GTI assessed on the Y-view explained a decrease of 3 CS points, 7° of flexion, and 5° of ER (p 76 years or < 119° varus angulation demonstrated the worst function. Linear prediction models estimated flexion, ER, and CS with a mean difference of 10°, 3°, and 3 points, respectively. The decision tree model predicted good function with 80% accuracy (positive predictive value = 81%; negative predictive value = 78%). Conclusion Demographic and radiographic predictors were identified allowing for accurate functional prognosis of nonoperatively treated PHF involving the surgical neck. A combined assessment of the ap-view in internal rotation and Y-view is sufficient for accurate function prediction. The identified subgroups resulting in good or impaired function, and the predictive models may be useful for patient counseling and guidance of treatment-related expectations.
surgery,orthopedics,sport sciences