Prioritizing Measures That Matter Within a Person-Centered Oncology Learning Health System
Aricca D Van Citters,Alice M Kennedy,Kathryn B Kirkland,Konstantin H Dragnev,Steven D Leach,Madge E Buus-Frank,Elissa F Malcolm,Megan M Holthoff,Anne B Holmes,Eugene C Nelson,Susan A Reeves,Anna N A Tosteson,Promise Partnership Delphi Panel,Albert Mulley,Amber Barnato,Amelia Cullinan,Andrew Williams,Ann Bradley,Anna Tosteson,Anne Holmes,Anne Ireland,Brant Oliver,Brock Christensen,Carol Majewski,Carolyn Kerrigan,Catherine Reed,Cathy Morrow,Corey Siegel,Daniel Jantzen,David Finley,Elissa Malcolm,Elizabeth Bengtson,Elizabeth McGrath,Elizabeth Stedina,Ellen Flaherty,Elliott Fisher,Eric Henderson,Erick Lansigan,Evan Benjamin,Gabriel Brooks,Garret Wasp,George Blike,Ira Byock,Janet Haines,Jenn Alford-Teaster,Jenna Schiffelbein,Jennifer Snide,Joanna Leyenaar,Jocelyn Chertoff,Joga Ivatury,Johanna Beliveau,John Sweetenham,Judith Rees,Julia Dalphin,Julie Kim,Karen Clements,Kathryn Kirkland,Kenneth Meehan,Konstantin Dragnev,Kris Bowen,Lawrence Dacey,Linton Evans,Malavika Govindan,Marcus Thygeson,Martha Goodrich,Mary Chamberlin,MaryAnn Stump,Matthew Mackwood,Matthew Wilson,Meredith Sorensen,Michael Calderwood,Paul Barr,Polly Campion,Ralph Jean-Mary,Rian M Hasson,Sai Cherala,Sally Kraft,Samuel Casella,Samuel Shields,Sandra Wong,Shoshana Hort,Stephanie Tomlin,Stephen Liu,Stephen LeBlanc,Steven Leach,Susan DiStasio,Susan Reeves,Virginia Reed,Wendy Wells,Whitney Hammond,Yolanda Sanchez
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/jncics/pkac037
2022-05-02
Abstract:Background: Despite progress in developing learning health systems (LHS) and associated metrics of success, a gap remains in identifying measures to guide the implementation and assessment of the impact of an oncology LHS. Our aim was to identify a balanced set of measures to guide a person-centered oncology LHS. Methods: A modified Delphi process and clinical value compass framework were used to prioritize measures for tracking LHS performance. A multidisciplinary group of 77 stakeholders, including people with cancer and family members, participated in 3 rounds of online voting followed by 50-minute discussions. Participants rated metrics on perceived importance to the LHS and discussed priorities. Results: Voting was completed by 94% of participants and prioritized 22 measures within 8 domains. Patient and caregiver factors included clinical health (Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group Performance Status, survival by cancer type and stage), functional health and quality of life (Patient Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System [PROMIS] Global-10, Distress Thermometer, Modified Caregiver Strain Index), experience of care (advance care planning, collaboRATE, PROMIS Self-Efficacy Scale, access to care, experience of care, end-of-life quality measures), and cost and resource use (avoidance and delay in accessing care and medications, financial hardship, total cost of care). Contextual factors included team well-being (Well-being Index; voluntary staff turnover); learning culture (Improvement Readiness, compliance with Commission on Cancer quality of care measures); scholarly engagement and productivity (institutional commitment and support for research, academic productivity index); and diversity, equity, inclusion, and belonging (screening and follow-up for social determinants of health, inclusivity of staff and patients). Conclusions: The person-centered LHS value compass provides a balanced set of measures that oncology practices can use to monitor and evaluate improvement across multiple domains.